|
IDEA
|
ArcGIS Pro 3.5.0 I've added a FGDB raster to my map. It has been placed at the top of the Contents pane by default. I've moved the layer midway down the Contents pane by dragging the layer. Once the layer has been moved, Pro automatically scrolls the Contents pane back to the top. That's annoying; I've lost my spot in the Contents pane. Idea: Don't scroll the Contents pane after moving a layer. Keep the Contents pane in the position of the moved layer.
... View more
07-06-2025
11:53 AM
|
3
|
2
|
510
|
|
POST
|
I work for a municipality in Ontario. We are starting to develop a Data Governance Plan. What types of data quality issues do you come across in your ArcGIS Pro data? For example: Data structure - difficult to query Data completeness - some records missing Data accuracy - data entered incorrectly; not reliable Out-of-date data - it was entered correctly at the time, but is now out of date Categories of data are missing, such as we have the asset records, but not condition information or historical cost information What else? And what is the top problem you face? If there were one data problem you could solve, what would it be?
... View more
06-24-2025
09:19 AM
|
0
|
1
|
1031
|
|
POST
|
Here are my updated questions: Who Who is making this request (what level of management)? Do you have senior management buy-in/approval? Are there any conflicts? Has anyone else already done this or is planning to do it? Who will provide the data? Who will be on the project team? Who will maintain the product and how often? What What do you want? Can you show us? Can you mockup an example in Excel or Illustrator, etc.? Give them what they need, this may not what they are asking for. What does "Done" look like? How will we know the work is completed to satisfaction? Consider getting a written answer to those questions to avoid wandering scope. What filetype/platform? Do you need a table, chart, print map, web map, or something else? What are the product dimensions/specs? When When will we have what we need to proceed? Where does it sit in our list of priorities? When do you need it by? Where Where is the data? Do the team members have access? Will the final product be sensitive, internal, or public? Who needs access? Where will the final product live and for how long? Why Why are we doing this? Why now? What happens if you don’t get it in time? What are you going to do with the final product? Does the product provide a good way to measure performance—such as measuring a team against a desired outcome? How How are we going to do the work? What's the plan? Cleaning Does the data exist? How reliable is it? Was the data entered correctly and is it easily query-able? How much data cleaning is required? How long will it take? Who will clean the data? Will we clean the source data or a copy of the data? How accurate do you need the analysis result/data to be? For example, if we were to estimate that the data is 95% accurate, is that sufficient? Notes from a colleague: #4 and 7 both sort of cover this but it's critical to ask if the data exists, how reliable is it? In Work Order Management software terms, failure analysis is pretty popular right now. Everyone wants to say they can help predict future failures. But the number of organizations that aren't even capturing failure data or are capturing it in free form fields (like long descriptions) where the same problem can be reported dozens of different ways by different people makes it really difficult. Even when the data is structured, such as using problem/cause/remedy, most companies don't have all the possible options. Things constantly end up in the wrong bucket because the fields are required but the correct option doesn't exist in the eyes of the technician. Even if you have the data, you can't necessarily get anything valuable out of it. Most analysis requests come from managers/executives that don't really understand the problem trying to be solved. You need the people that are capturing the data to explain how they capture it and the challenges they have with capturing it reliably. #5 the first question "why are we doing this" and the follow up question (in my eyes, don't see it here) is "what are we going to do with this" is extremely critical to me. Managers love KPIs because it gives a way to measure the team against some desired outcome. For example, if you want to focus on quality, you will set objectives for number of defects. If you want to focus on customer service, you'll set objectives for time to resolution for example. Neither of these are inherently bad. But you have to be careful. KPIs often lead to undesirable outcomes, especially if people (managers and/or employees) are incentivized by the KPI. In software, if you measure teams on the number of bugs, genuine issues with the product are "working as designed". Customer service will close cases as soon as they respond even if the issue isn't resolved from the customer perspective. You essentially change the behavior of employees to meet the KPI but at the end of the day, your customer (internal or external) isn't benefitting from the changes. Then in 6 months when customer satisfaction is down, the KPIs are changed to try and achieve that objective. And the cycle continues on and on.
... View more
06-23-2025
08:24 AM
|
0
|
0
|
3385
|
|
IDEA
|
@KoryKramer Let me know if you need a separate idea for "Include column header when copying selected cells". "When you say you want to copy to clipboard, what do you need to do with the copied cells afterwards?" Answer: Paste into Excel, Word, or Outlook.
... View more
06-23-2025
06:59 AM
|
0
|
0
|
992
|
|
IDEA
|
ArcGIS Pro 3.4.3 In the domains view, I would like to select some domains and copy them to the clipboard, including the Name column and other domain property columns. This is a separate request from functionality in the Generate Schema Report tool. https://community.esri.com/t5/arcgis-pro-ideas/export-arcgis-pro-domains-view-to-table-or/idi-p/1139970 It would be fast/consistent/intuitive to be able to do this right from the domains view.
... View more
06-19-2025
08:26 AM
|
4
|
0
|
427
|
|
IDEA
|
For what it's worth, in Pro 3.4.3 and 3.5.0, I'm not able to copy the list of domain names to the clipboard (not to be confused with the domain values).
... View more
06-18-2025
09:09 AM
|
0
|
0
|
493
|
|
IDEA
|
Esri mentioned the info below in an message about documentation feedback: ArcGIS Pro was previously applying a spatial filter when querying for all rows in a spatial table, which was incorrect and led to fields without a spatial value being excluded. That was fixed in ArcGIS Pro 3.3, though. The behavior across the platform can be inconsistent if the table does not contain unique ID values or if you create a join that results in duplicate ID values, which makes it difficult to state exactly what behavior you will encounter. That is why we opted for the general statement about the unique ID requirement. That said, though, I notice that the page on which you commented does not include the statement about the unique ID. I suppose it wasn’t called out because all layers—not just query layers—must have a unique ID. But I think we can add a bullet to the list of things to keep in mind and link it to the unique identifier fields page. Other things that would prevent you from seeing all the rows are mentioned in each page about creating a query layer. They’re the spatial property settings. I’ll see if I can work in a bullet about those too. @JonathanNeal, should this idea be closed?
... View more
06-09-2025
06:29 PM
|
0
|
0
|
2027
|
|
POST
|
I am also seeing the problem still. I'm not able to help with troubleshooting either, as I have moved to a different position.
... View more
06-09-2025
01:28 AM
|
0
|
0
|
1664
|
|
POST
|
A general question about managing data analysis projects. What questions do you ask the requester? Who is making this request (what level of management)? Who is the intended audience? Who will be on the project team? What do you want? Can you mock up a rough example in Excel or Illustrator, etc.? What filetype/platform? When do you need it by? Where is the data? Where will the final product live and for how long? Who needs access to the final product? Why are we doing this? Why now? What happens if you don’t get it in time? How are we going to do the work? What's the plan? Cleaning - How much data cleaning is required? How long will it take? Will we clean the source data or a copy of the data? How accurate do you need the analysis result/data to be? For example, if we were to guess that the data is 95% accurate, is that sufficient? Those questions are just a stab in the dark. What questions do you ask when taking on a data analysis project? I ask because I'm moving to a new team and am looking to develop some techniques for success to avoid the usual pitfalls of data analysis projects.
... View more
05-28-2025
12:54 PM
|
0
|
5
|
3715
|
|
IDEA
|
For read-only layers, table views, and joins that are slow due to complex querying: Right-click the Contents layer and choose a new Pause Re-query option. The data would be cached in RAM until manually refreshed. This would improve performance without the messiness of exporting to a FGDB.
... View more
05-25-2025
09:54 AM
|
2
|
1
|
633
|
|
IDEA
|
ArcGIS Pro 3.5.0 I wonder if it would be useful to be able to use operations like OR and NOT in spatial definition clauses. Currently, only AND seems to be available. I haven't fully wrapped my head around possible use cases. Maybe someone else can say something smart here.
... View more
05-19-2025
09:55 PM
|
3
|
3
|
919
|
|
IDEA
|
ArcGIS Pro 3.5.0 In the main Definition Query tab in the layer properties, the layer name used in the spatial definition clause is not displayed. See red circle. I'm wondering if the layer name could be included in the Geometry button in the spatial definition clause. There's not much space, so if the layer name gets truncated, then a tool tip should be available to display the full layer name. I think that would be better than forcing the user to open the Spatial Clause Geometry dialog to see what layer is being used. And for what it's worth, that dialog doesn't do a very good job of showing what layer is used either. Spatial Definition Query — Highlight chosen layer
... View more
05-19-2025
09:33 PM
|
3
|
0
|
515
|
|
IDEA
|
Spatial Definition Queries: I’m wondering if it would be beneficial to select multiple layers of the same geometry type, such as multiple polygon layers, to be used for the spatial definition query intersect. For example, use CTRL+Click or checkboxes to select multiple intersect layers. Related: Multiple spatial definition query clauses Union Feature Layer — Group layers with identical schemas into a single layer; apply properties to g... New Query Layer: Union
... View more
05-17-2025
08:57 AM
|
4
|
1
|
749
|
| Title | Kudos | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 03-20-2026 02:12 PM | |
| 1 | 03-19-2026 11:42 AM | |
| 1 | 06-03-2026 04:02 AM | |
| 1 | 03-18-2026 07:08 PM | |
| 2 | 3 weeks ago |