Use IDE for writing Arcade expressions

[Bud]

Do developers use an IDE when writing lengthy Arcade expressions? (specifically Calculation Attribute Rules)

Example:
https://github.com/Esri/arcade-expressions/blob/master/Industry/Gas/Calculation/Assembly-Generate_ID...

What's your workflow?
Do you write (and save) the script in an IDE, and then paste it into ArcGIS Pro to see if it runs?
Or something else?

Thanks.

[Luke_Pinner]

I use Visual Studio Code with the language set to Javascript. Seems other users do too. Not ideal but ok for syntax highlighting. Any IDE that supports JS should work.

You can just copy/paste between VSCode and Pro, but you might be able to save in your IDE and load in Pro. I use Arcade for popup configs and save as a .lxp (Label Expression File (LXP)) which is plain text format in VSCode then import in the popup expression builder.  You might be able to do the same for attribute expressions.

[jcarlson]

Agreed, I use VSCode for developing mine. Especially when working on Data Expressions in Dashboards, where you can't properly save your expression until it's returning a FeatureSet. I've toyed with the idea of making a language extension, but the standard JS settings work well enough. I would really like some intellisense popups, though.

[MikeMillerGIS]

I use pycharm, as I do mostly python development.  I typically save my arcade as .js files.  For the most part it works pretty good.  @PaulLeBlanc1  put together this syntax for arcade in n++ a while back.  Probably needs to be updated for some of the new methods.

[JohannesLindner]

I'm severely limited by IT restrictions. No chance to get an IDE or even Notepad++. I only have access to Python because it comes with ArcGIS, I can't get packages other than the ones that are preinstalled...

So, I use the expression window in ArcGIS Pro, even for really long expressions. It needs a button to maximize it, but else it's doable.

[Bud]

For what it's worth, I don't have admin privileges on my work computer either (Windows 10). Yet, I noticed that I could install VS Code without needing admin rights. The same applies to some SQL clients and even R.

I just thought I'd mention that.
At first, I assumed there'd be no way to get an IDE like VS Code without admin rights. But to my surprise, it worked.

[Bud]

For software that requires admin privileges, I sometimes resort to using my home computer, on fake data. It's not great, but sometimes it's better than not having the software at all on my work computer.

[KevinDohner]

I know this is a somewhat old discussion board, but for anyone else who comes across this page like I did with this question, ESRI has a Playground for Arcade that looks like anyone can use and doesn't need a login or anything. The playground can be found here: Playground | ArcGIS Arcade | Esri Developer.

I too was thinking about using VS Code but wanting Intellisense and this playground seems to fit my needs.