Latest Contributions by JaySandhu

What version of ArcGIS Pro are you using? I am trying to understand the workflow and the observed behavior. You start Pro, create a closest facility layer, import facilities, and incidents and the solve to get routes. Now you close the project without saving it at anytime after the CF layer was created. When you reopen the project, there is NO closest facility layer in the TOC but you are seeing facilities, incidents and routes on the map. There is no corresponding layer in the TOC for what is visible on the map.  Is this is what you are running into, it should not happen. But if it happens, it could be some locally cached map data that did not get cleared. You can try deleting the local map cache and see if that resolves the problem. In ArcGIS Pro click on Project and then on Options. On the options popup, click on Display tab, scroll a bit down to see the Local cache and then click on the Clear Cache Now button below it. Hopefully that will resolve the problem. Jay Sandhu ... View more

Once data is loaded from a feature class to a facilities or incidents layer it becomes independent of where the data came from. Deleting rows from a facilities or incidents layer does not impact the original feature class. Jay Sandhu ... View more

You should use Maximize Capacitated Coverage. This will look at the capacity.  The option you used to Maximize Coverage and Minimize Facilities is about maximizing how much demand it can cover in the cutoff distance. It does not look at the capacity settings. Jay Sandhu ... View more

Do you have your own local copy of the Streetmap Premium that you are using? Not AGOL. I tried using AGOL with your data and scenario and the route worked fine. Gave me a route with 475.5 Km. It could be an issue with the version of SMP data you have and the hierarchy settings. So, try turning off hierarchy and then resolve. The hierarchy setting is on the same area when you are changing restrictions, expand the advanced section and turn hierarchy off. Jay Sandhu ... View more

In service area, the facilities can be loaded with a "delay" in terms of the cost attribute being used to solve the service area. For example, if you want to do a 4 minute service area and a facility was set to have a 1 minute delay then it will only create a 3 minute service area. The "delay" is per facility. Here is a screen shot of three facilities with delay set to 0, 1 and 2 and the subsequent 4 minute service areas.       You need to set up a network dataset with a cost attribute set up in terms of $ per mile then you can use the delay concept to load the facilities with the trash fee at that facility and generate your polygons.  However, if you are planning to use the online service, it does not have a cost per mile attribute. Regards, Jay Sandhu Jay Sandhu ... View more

It is not clear what you are trying to achieve. You have locations of dump sites and prices in the first picture. In the second picture you have two start locations and two dump sites. The price of $25 per mile adds another variable.  If a consumer is trying to make a decision than they would simply go to the "nearest" dump site minus the price they pay. So Point B can go to the $75 dump as long as the distance to that dump is less than 5 miles after which the dump with $200 price is cheaper. What kind of polygons are you trying to produce? What defines a "polygon"? Jay Sandhu ... View more

Generally speaking, there is no setting on Location-Allocation to set a minimum threshold on a facility. However, you could screen sites that are not feasible. For example, you must have some sort of distance or travel time constraint for reaching the 1000 people, eliminate the candidates that do not have a 1000 people within your cutoff. Not saying that this will give you the desired results, just improves the chances. You can also do an iterative approach. Solve for X sites, remove ones that do not meet the minimum criteria and solve again. Regards, Jay Sandhu ... View more

I am not sure what it means to not change route direction. Can you explain what you need to accomplish?  Jay Sandhu ... View more

If your goal is to delay a path, and you have that path as some line feature, then you can load it into a route analysis layer as a Line Barrier with scaled cost. Set the cost with the amount of delay. See more here: Barriers—ArcGIS Pro | Documentation Jay Sandhu ... View more

It is hard to say what could be going on. Are you using the online logistics service or local street data network? Perhaps the street data has an invalid spatial index causing the search to be slow or access to the data is slow if it is on an external/cloud drive. You can try creating a fresh project and recreating the layer and see if that fixes the issue. Beyond that you will need to share the VRP layer/data with tech support so they can help diagnose what could be going on. Jay Sandhu ... View more

Are you solving a Location-Allocation problem or Vehicle Routing Problem? How many inputs are being added? i.e. the size maybe large and it might be computing a large cost matrix to start the analysis. Jay Sandhu   ... View more

Generally you can use the Location-Allocation solver for warehouse locations. It will minimize distance to the places you want to deliver to. The inputs are the location of your demand points (places to deliver to) and the candidate facilities from which you can pick your warehouses. You need to use your consumer characteristics and anything else that is important to find a list of suitable candidates that you can input to the location-allocation solver and then solve for the optimal number based on how far you want to deliver to (cutoff). See more here: Network Analyst solvers—ArcGIS Pro | Documentation and Location-allocation analysis layer—ArcGIS Pro | Documentation Jay Sandhu ... View more