coffeyjr3

Optional versus Required GP Parameters for Python Script Tool

Discussion created by coffeyjr3 on Aug 10, 2011
I published a Python script tool as a GP service in ArcServer.  This script has a number of parameters (17 at the moment and possibly more as time goes by).  Only two parameters are required.  However, when I call the GPService from Silverlight (in C#), I have to specify ALL of the parameters, even the "optional" ones.  If I do not pass a value for ALL parameters, the task fails with "ESRI.ArcGIS.Client.Tasks.ServiceException: Error Submitting Job."  If I do pass a value for each parameter, the job runs fine.

Here's my issue: This service will be called from many Silverlight/ArcServer apps, and I would like to be able to add another optional parameter without breaking every app that calls the service.  By adding a parameter, I will be effectively requiring each developer to republish their code to include a parameter their app probably doesn't care about.

Do I misunderstand the significance of setting a parameter to Optional versus Required?

(I will also post this in the Silverlight forum.)

Thanks for any advice/suggestions.

Outcomes