Jared:
The order of the coordinates you are referencing can make a difference in how they are interpreted. It looks like the coordinates are returned as latitude (y), longitude ( x) vs longitude ( x), latitude (y). If you entered -119.76 as longitude and 36.73 as latitude you would get the location returned in California if you are using the Go To XY tool in ArcMap.
-Shana
I've said before; The G in GIS is not Google.....