Sorry, but this is not the correct way to "change a coordinate system".
Do NOT redefine the coordinate system to something it is not.
1. Use the project tool, to create a new feature in the coordinate system of choice (in your case GCS).
or
2. Load the metres based data (I hope you know what this coord sys is, UTM perhaps) into ArcMap, then change the coordinate system of the data frame to a GCS based system. Then you can export the data in the CRS of the DF.