Oh, it's not the selection on the map itself, it's the cursor! I can't get my cursor back to a normal one to do things like move the map because this stays toggled on:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77aed/77aeda562a79c610bbda886f31944cf7fa100cce" alt="AcdenHelios_0-1661262947710.png AcdenHelios_0-1661262947710.png"
I thought if I clicked it again that it would turn it off, but all is does is drop the menu down to pick a different kind of selection.