Ability to Set Default Transformations for Geoprocessing and Maps in ArcGIS Pro

1064
4
09-21-2022 10:41 AM
Status: Open
Labels (1)
fklotz
by
Regular Contributor

ArcGIS Pro has certain default transformations that it applies to new maps. Organizations may have their own standard transformations that should be used for certain geographies and certain geographic coordinate system combinations. The ability to override the ESRI defined default transformations should be in the options so that GIS users within these organizations do not have to re-set every map from the sometimes long and confusing list of assumed to be correct transformations for the data in the map.

There was an Idea for ArcMap which contains good comments here: Ability to set another default datum transformatio... - Esri Community

In the post above

it would be nice to also have the option to establish default transformations to use with the default spatial reference.

For example, if the default spatial reference for new maps is set to some zone of the SPCS using NAD 83, then to also have the option to set the default transformation to be used if WGS84 data is added to the map, and the default to be used if NAD 27 data is added to the map, etc...

For many offices, most of the data added to their maps typically use the same two or three different datums, so having the option to set default transformations for these datums to their map's default spatial reference would alleviate the bulk of transformation warnings that consistently arise whenever data is added to new maps, and relegate the warning to only those rare times when data not accounted for with a default transformation is added to the map.

Tags (1)
4 Comments
RobertSistersonYCC

I support this idea as it would be very useful for us here in Australia as we've got a relatively new national datum (GDA 2020) and there are a range of transformation options available and which you choose can depend on your industry & what part of the country you are in. We're a local council and would like to standardise a transformation across the organisation to remove uncertainty for our users and deliver higher assurance on our data.

JohnAnderson1

Yes, +1 for this enhancement please. Same issue as @RobertSistersonYCC  above.

Australia are adopting an new national datum - GDA2020. Currently ArcGIS Pro's default transformation between Web Mercator and GDA2020 is set to:

https://epsg.io/9688

...which assumes a null transformation between Web Mercator Basemaps and data being displayed in GDA2020. But instead, our Web Mercator basemaps for the state I work in currently require a null transformation between Web Mercator and GDA94 to properly align. We need to use a different default transformation. Manually changing the transformation method for every ArcGIS Pro project is very time consuming and not a practical solution.

LenOlyott2

Agree, this is creating big issues for us in Queensland, AU. ArcGIS Pro and ArcGIS Online assumes the best transformation is GDA 1994 to WGS 1984 2 when we actually need to use the one that has null transformation

BMaunder

Bumping this in 2024. Another Australian who is seeing many issues:

 - Users not knowing (or forgetting) about correct transformations to use between WGS84, GDA94, GDA2020 and accepting the defaults within ArcGIS Pro which are usually incorrect in our case. Frequent GDA94/GDA2020 mis-alignment issues due to this.
 - Introduces loss in productivity by having to manually select the correct transformation every time in each new ArcGIS Pro map or tool.

Being able to specify default or favourite transformations between select datums would be extremely useful.