Hi @Wade , MapImageLayer's work a little differently than the layers that support layer views, hit tests and highlighting.  For a replacement for highlighting with MapImageLayer I'd suggest creating a GraphicsLayer and adding it to the map.  Then with the feature returned from the Identify you can add a graphic to the GraphicsLayer.  You'll also need to set the IdentifyParameters to return the geometry.  I wrote a quick codepen that shows how this can be done, by modifying our normal Identify sample to add a graphic.  I hope this helps, although MapImageLayers can draw faster, they do have trade offs compared to using FeatureLayers.
https://codepen.io/sagewall/pen/ExGQLGJ?editors=1010