Karl,
I'm not sure this is the problem, but I thought it was worth point out.
arcpy.PointToRaster_conversion(feature class name, "Value", out data name, "MEAN", "Vaule", 10000)
First you have a syntax error I'm assuming "Vaule" should be "Value".
Secondly, the 5th parameter, which is priority field should only be used when you use the MOST_FREQUENT cell assignment(4th parameter). It should probably left just a blank string when you use "Mean" cell assignment. This may or may not have anything to do with you getting the wrong values.
arcpy.PointToRaster_conversion(feature class name, "Value", out data name, "MEAN", "", 10000)