Sketch Editor hard crash in MAUI

[hayer]

Sketch Editor makes the program crash when moving a vertex. Deleting vertices works fine.

Happens when using;

• Esri.ArcGISRuntime.Maui version 100.14.0-preview2  (also happend in earlier versions)
• Esri.ArcGISRuntime.WinUI version 100.14.0

Exception

Faulting application name: MyProgam.exe, version: 1.0.0.0, time stamp: 0x62571213
Faulting module name: CoreMessagingXP.dll, version: 10.0.22467.1020, time stamp: 0xcb3186f5
Exception code: 0xc000027b
Fault offset: 0x0000000000095b2c
Faulting process ID: 0x0x10A0
Faulting application start time: 0x0x1D866AD9E26D744
Faulting application path: C:\Users\<...>\MyProgram.exe
Faulting module path: C:\Program Files\WindowsApps\Microsoft.WindowsAppRuntime.1.0_3.469.1654.0_x64__8wekyb3d8bbwe\CoreMessagingXP.dll
Report ID: 96db5917-feb8-4250-b12a-3870ea711455
Faulting package full name: 42b5bb5f-a561-4075-b936-0286994fd075_1.0.0.1_x64__9zz4h110yvjzm
Faulting package-relative application ID: App

TargetFramework is net6.0-windows10.0.19041
TargetPlatformMinVersion is 10.0.19041.0

Edit:

One, of many, offending polygons

{"rings":[[[28.309655000000078,70.540905000000066],[28.403449000000023,70.510430000000042],[28.399771000000044,70.500051000000042],[28.35941500000007,70.487775000000056],[28.33516000000003,70.476974000000041],[28.309078000000056,70.450761000000057],[28.304184000000078,70.446040000000039],[28.295386000000065,70.439965000000029],[28.28324200000003,70.433109000000059],[28.268496000000027,70.425224000000071],[28.25207400000005,70.418677000000059],[28.227295000000026,70.410380000000032],[28.223170000000039,70.408862000000056],[28.218629000000078,70.406914000000029],[28.215925000000027,70.405530000000056],[28.213705000000061,70.404005000000041],[28.200345000000027,70.405896000000041],[28.199266000000023,70.405929000000071],[28.199054000000046,70.405939000000046],[28.198916000000054,70.405992000000083],[28.194075000000055,70.40670300000005],[28.192904000000055,70.406964000000073],[28.181576000000064,70.409444000000065],[28.179857000000027,70.408524000000057],[28.178476000000046,70.409169000000077],[28.175197000000026,70.409530000000075],[28.171282000000076,70.409568000000036],[28.165715000000034,70.409115000000043],[28.165634000000068,70.409203000000048],[28.165445000000034,70.409338000000048],[28.165144000000055,70.409470000000056],[28.164892000000066,70.409635000000037],[28.164721000000043,70.409825000000069],[28.164509000000066,70.410019000000034],[28.164243000000056,70.410283000000049],[28.164035000000069,70.410371000000055],[28.163829000000078,70.410431000000074],[28.163745000000063,70.410492000000033],[28.163700000000063,70.410584000000028],[28.163732000000039,70.410669000000041],[28.163766000000066,70.410845000000052],[28.163861000000054,70.410942000000034],[28.163830000000075,70.411027000000047],[28.163722000000064,70.411110000000065],[28.163490000000024,70.411156000000062],[28.163278000000048,70.41121400000003],[28.163042000000075,70.411332000000073],[28.162894000000051,70.411421000000075],[28.162751000000071,70.411577000000079],[28.162631000000033,70.411681000000044],[28.162418000000059,70.411737000000073],[28.162083000000052,70.411801000000082],[28.161881000000051,70.411914000000081],[28.16161100000005,70.412030000000073],[28.157516000000044,70.414259000000072],[28.129609000000073,70.415067000000079],[28.115793000000053,70.42289500000004],[28.143167000000062,70.441414000000066],[28.155598000000055,70.447324000000037],[28.171614000000034,70.45575000000008],[28.185207000000048,70.460771000000079],[28.196145000000058,70.465699000000029],[28.235099000000048,70.468457000000058],[28.274880000000053,70.478925000000061],[28.284531000000072,70.493888000000084],[28.320109000000059,70.498712000000069],[28.318239000000062,70.506216000000052],[28.309655000000078,70.540905000000066]]],"spatialReference":{"wkid":4258}}  

[PreetiMaske]

Hi,

I ported over forms SketchOnMap sample to MAUI and tried deleting the vertex and did not see any crash. Would you like to share your test app with a simple repro? I would be happy to try and see if I can reproduce it as well.

Thanks,

Preeti

[hayer]

Thanks for taking your time to test it.

Deleting vertices works fine. Its moving any of them which causes the crash. It doesn't happen for all polygons - only some. Seems to be more common polygons with many vertices, >200. Don't have the data accessible right now but I will post one of the offending polygons later to night 🙂

[hayer]

{"rings":[[[28.309655000000078,70.540905000000066],[28.403449000000023,70.510430000000042],[28.399771000000044,70.500051000000042],[28.35941500000007,70.487775000000056],[28.33516000000003,70.476974000000041],[28.309078000000056,70.450761000000057],[28.304184000000078,70.446040000000039],[28.295386000000065,70.439965000000029],[28.28324200000003,70.433109000000059],[28.268496000000027,70.425224000000071],[28.25207400000005,70.418677000000059],[28.227295000000026,70.410380000000032],[28.223170000000039,70.408862000000056],[28.218629000000078,70.406914000000029],[28.215925000000027,70.405530000000056],[28.213705000000061,70.404005000000041],[28.200345000000027,70.405896000000041],[28.199266000000023,70.405929000000071],[28.199054000000046,70.405939000000046],[28.198916000000054,70.405992000000083],[28.194075000000055,70.40670300000005],[28.192904000000055,70.406964000000073],[28.181576000000064,70.409444000000065],[28.179857000000027,70.408524000000057],[28.178476000000046,70.409169000000077],[28.175197000000026,70.409530000000075],[28.171282000000076,70.409568000000036],[28.165715000000034,70.409115000000043],[28.165634000000068,70.409203000000048],[28.165445000000034,70.409338000000048],[28.165144000000055,70.409470000000056],[28.164892000000066,70.409635000000037],[28.164721000000043,70.409825000000069],[28.164509000000066,70.410019000000034],[28.164243000000056,70.410283000000049],[28.164035000000069,70.410371000000055],[28.163829000000078,70.410431000000074],[28.163745000000063,70.410492000000033],[28.163700000000063,70.410584000000028],[28.163732000000039,70.410669000000041],[28.163766000000066,70.410845000000052],[28.163861000000054,70.410942000000034],[28.163830000000075,70.411027000000047],[28.163722000000064,70.411110000000065],[28.163490000000024,70.411156000000062],[28.163278000000048,70.41121400000003],[28.163042000000075,70.411332000000073],[28.162894000000051,70.411421000000075],[28.162751000000071,70.411577000000079],[28.162631000000033,70.411681000000044],[28.162418000000059,70.411737000000073],[28.162083000000052,70.411801000000082],[28.161881000000051,70.411914000000081],[28.16161100000005,70.412030000000073],[28.157516000000044,70.414259000000072],[28.129609000000073,70.415067000000079],[28.115793000000053,70.42289500000004],[28.143167000000062,70.441414000000066],[28.155598000000055,70.447324000000037],[28.171614000000034,70.45575000000008],[28.185207000000048,70.460771000000079],[28.196145000000058,70.465699000000029],[28.235099000000048,70.468457000000058],[28.274880000000053,70.478925000000061],[28.284531000000072,70.493888000000084],[28.320109000000059,70.498712000000069],[28.318239000000062,70.506216000000052],[28.309655000000078,70.540905000000066]]],"spatialReference":{"wkid":4258}}

[dotMorten_esri]

I haven't been able to reproduce this either. Any chance you could share a small sample that reproduces this behavior?

[hayer]

GitHub repo with repro;

hayer/ArcGisSketchEditorCrash: ArcGIS SketchEditor crash repro in MAUI (github.com)

[hayer]

@dotMorten_esri any idea what might be causing this?

@PreetiMaske feel free to take a look at the repo linked above 🙂

[dotMorten_esri · Accepted solution]

Thanks for the repro. I'm able to reproduce now. There's a limitation in the sketch editor editing geometries in a different spatial reference than the mapview. Granted that error could be better and shouldn't crash like this, but for now, you can address it by reprojecting before editing:

var editedGeom = await mapView.SketchEditor.StartAsync(GeometryEngine.Project(geom, map.SpatialReference));

[hayer]

Ah, okay! Thanks. Didn't think that would cause an issue, and as you state the error message could maybe be a tad better.

Using workaround you suggested for now.