Robert, that's exactly what's happening. For some reason, this one exterior polygon, out of the 45,000+ in the shp file, is clockwise and the interior polygons are counterclockwise. Therefore, the interior ones show up shaded and the exterior polygon not. I ran check and repair geometry to no avail. The interior polygons are actually exterior polygons for another value in the table. If I import the shp file into CAD and reverse the direction of the polyline and then export it as a shp file, it does not recognize the interior polygons. Is there no way to reverse direction in Arc?