@JessMiller1 What locator was used to geocode your table? If you are using a custom locator based on reference data that has a projection of NAD_1983_StatePlane_North_Carolina_FIPS_3200_Feet, then the locator will output the result in that coordinate system. The coordinates in your screenshot are US Feet. There are a few things you can do :
1. In the Geocode Addresses dialog specify a different coordinate system for the output.
2. If using the Geocode Addresses geoprocessing tool, click environments button and expand output coordinate system and specify a geographic coordinate system
3. You could use the Project geoprocessing tool to reproject the geocode result to a geographic coordinate system like WGS 1984, then use the result in the Add XY Coordinates tool.