Hi Grace
That is weird, this morning your post was displaying under ArcGIS Earth but now under ArcGIS Pro. But not important.
I see now that when I created the screen grab for you, I accidentally checked the wrong box. My mistake. The text is correct but not the screen-grab. Please make sure you check the Use Input Features for Clipping Geometry check-box.
One should be careful when clipping a raster and using the Maintain Clipping Extent option as it alters the geometry of the original input raster by trying to ensure that it fits exactly within the clipping polygon, so it may assign a new starting coordinate and subsequently resample the raster pixels which is never good practice when working with rasters. The resulting output will most likely be slightly less accurate than the original input raster.
Another option for you to try will be to set the extent and mask. Setting the mask is another one of the Environment settings option but available under the Analysis tab and the Geoprocessing group. Do see the below screen grab. When working with rasters I often set these two options but afterwards I try and make a point of changing it back to the defaults otherwise 6 months from now it can cause some head scratching when rerunning a different tool in the same Pro project.