I gave up and did it in Arcmap in 5 minutes after wasting an hour setting up the map in AGP.
AGP is a super waste of time.
Hi Sharon,
Here's a workflow that worked for me, though I'm sure there are other ways!
Here's a link to a video of that workflow: 12.05.2018-09.11.50
Wow, thanks, this worked great! I didn't know you could do it like that.
While this did work great, since I had given up, I made the map in Arcmap and that came out much better than the one in AGP.
The World Topographic basemap in AGP does not have the actual contours on it, but the one in ArcMap does. I hope the developers of AGP get on it or I'm just not going to keep using AGP.