Select to view content in your preferred language

Map Viewer Interface - Questioning Design Choices

148
0
07-01-2025 06:00 PM
RTPL_AU
Honored Contributor

I was wondering how the Map Viewer styles and design choices came about.

This is unselected but highlighted:

RTPL_AU_0-1751416954006.png

This is selected:

RTPL_AU_1-1751416982102.png

While making a lot of changes to various layers, as you do while laying out a map to be useable, I often find myself selecting a layer that is already selected. 

This is due to the same optical 'issues' humans have that make these type of illusions so fun when in a magazine.
How many black dots do you see?

RTPL_AU_4-1751417238372.png

Find the black dot:

RTPL_AU_6-1751417697131.png

The size/spacing of the objects in the Map Viewer contents area are 'just right' so that the 'selected' bar is invisible when you are focusing on other parts of the UI. 

I would assume a proper company like Esri has designers that understand these concepts.
There are a few options at play:

  1. This issue was considered but .....?
  2. This issue was not considered. Remedy = don't give important jobs to the work experience student.
  3. Focus groups said it looked sick?


Therefore, and this is a serious question, why was the UI design made in this way? 

 

Should we have to lodge Ideas that pertain to proper design? 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

0 Kudos
0 Replies