I don't know why the Excel change doesn't stick. If you have ETGeowizards available use it to change column order. XTools may be able to do the same. If not you can create a blank dataset with the fields in the order you want and then copy and paste the records from your current table into it. Or you can add temporary fields, use the calculator to copy data into them, reorder the fields you will keep by deleting and adding, then copy the data from the temp fields back into the reordered fields and delete the temp.