Hi c1ory6,
One way you could solve your problem is to trace the shorelines of your respective maps as lines or polygon feature classes on the same geodatabase. This is very old school, but it works great, and is sometimes easier than the headaches and heartaches incurred by trying to get outdated software to work.
Make sure you use the same datum and projection, so that if you were to do analysis on them like acres lost, your math will be correct.
There are some lovely sea level rise interactive mappers available on the internet, too, to check your work. Here's one: https://coast.noaa.gov/digitalcoast/tools/slr.html
I did a sea level rise project for one of my classes which I will share with you. I used DEMs (digital elevation models).
Good luck on your project.