Hey @TulsaCommunity_College 

I don't believe that tool works 100% of the time for shapefiles, what you may try doing is dragging and dropping the shapefile into ArcGIS Pro, and then right-click -> export it into a file geodatabase by redirecting the output from its default location, and set it to the file geodatabase. That's what I've done with all of my imports so far as sometimes tools may take too long!

Cody