Nope... I live at latitude 45ish North our northing is in the 5,000,000ish range... you are further north, ergo your northing would be greater than mine since you are further north and the northing is measured from the equator as a reference point... so you eastings and northings surely are not UTM. They have been alter to some other base reference and/or they are in a different projection.
So, did you find the correct projection? If not, you may be able to get to the right one by altering the UTM Zone 11 CRS properties (double-click UTM Zone 11 to get to properties). The scale parameter may be different, though.
i worked on the other files and they matched up excellent in ArcMap, using the above methods; save to x,y extent, add fields, and finally convert to shapefile and calculate the geometry. I also know there is a batch file converter in arcmap, i haven't played with it yet. My goal is/was to make a data model in model builder of the process and let the engineers(people) convert their hearts out. Its not so easy!