What are the 10 most important GIS skills to nurture in teaching with GIS?
In high school, my friend and I had ongoing debates about the "Top 10 coolest bands of all time." We never could win each other to "our side" of the argument, but it was fun to discuss anyway. Nowadays, perhaps because of the flood of information, because of time constraints and the need for concise pieces of information, and because it offers a place for anyone to have a voice, the web is full of Top 10 lists. These include those on the "Top 10 places to visit in <fill in your state or country> before you die", the "Top 10 most influential people in history", and on and on. These lists are often subjective, sometimes fun to read, sometimes can be informative, but can often serve as effective "conversation starters" in class in debate or in other instructional scenarios. This essay is provided in video form, here.
In today's complex and rapidly changing education and technology environment, where educators need to focus on "what really matters", such a Top 10 GIS based skills list could be valuable. Therefore, I ask, you, the reader, to think about: "What are the 10 most important skills to nurture and develop for success in using GIS in instruction?"
Let me reassure you here at the outset that I do not believe that these are the only types of skills that teaching with GIS fosters. Indeed, my colleagues and I have written extensively about the inquiry, communication, and other skills fostered by working with spatial data and geotechnologies in this blog, in videos, and in journal articles, and elsewhere. Furthermore, since GIS instruction always is about real issues in real contexts, whether it is natural hazards, species richness, soils or landforms, climate and weather, population change and demographics, social justice, or other key 21st Century issues, students are gaining content knowledge in a wide array of disciplines when they are using GIS in instruction. In addition, I believe that GIS offers spatial thinking, systems thinking, holistic thinking, and other perspectives far beyond skills and content knowledge. See my 3-legged stool of geoliteracy for more on this topic. And we could certainly talk about the broader skills that GIS fosters in managing projects, working with data types, formats, and delivery mechanisms (portals, Hubs; streaming vs. downloading), and learning attitudes such as embracing change, asking questions, and others. But for this essay, let's focus on core GIS skills.
While any "Top 10" list is rightly open to debate, and I welcome that debate in the comments to this essay, I would argue that if you and your students master these 10 skills, you can do virtually anything in this exciting and powerful platform! Do I really mean anything? Yes, because I believe teaching your students these skills is like teaching them "how to fish"--they develop the perspectives and problem-solving abilities that they can transfer to different issues and regions. This education community blog is filled with examples of students doing amazing things, from primary to secondary to university (read more here and here) and beyond.
The Top 10 GIS Skills
This list can be used to create assessment tools if you are teaching a course or a workshop. The entire list or portions thereof could also be used as a pre-test for a workshop you are planning--what are attendees' skills before they begin? It could be compared to a post-workshop evaluation using a variety of assessment instruments. I like having students create ArcGIS Story Maps, for example, as content that I can evaluate technically and also to make sure students understand the concept (such as tsunamis or population change). I can assess the maps online and also assess a 5-minute live or recorded oral presentation that the students give as they walk their peers and me through their story map.
While my essay title is focused on "ArcGIS Online", I contend that many of these skills are important in using other GIS software such as ArcGIS Pro, ArcGIS Urban, ArcGIS Insights, Business Analyst Web, and even non-Esri GIS software. But those other software sets involve developing some unique skills as well, such as understanding how to bring data from a GIS to a statistical package and back, for example, using the R Bridge in ArcGIS Pro.
Certainly there are "honorable mentions" that I would like to include in this list, such as (1) developing coding skills in JavaScript and Python which powers the web maps, and (2) editing point, line, and polygon mapped features. But I cut myself off at 10 !
Other GIS skill lists are worth examining: My colleagues and I in the T3G (Teachers Teaching Teachers GIS) program organized the core elements of GIS into: Create geographic data, analyze data, and visualize data. USC, for example, groups the skills into data collection and evaluation, visualization, analysis, and modeling. I also like this list from Oregon State University for its nudge about understanding workflows and from GIS Lounge for its focus on data. And I have long been a proponent of the Geospatial Technology Competency Model from the GeoTech Center that begins with personal competencies: "Are you organized? Are you ethical? Can you work with data?"
What skills, in your judgement, are most important in the above list? What skills would you include in such a list? Which of these 10 skills apply to using other tools, such as ArcGIS Pro? What skills do you think might decrease or increase in importance as we move forward in this current decade?
I look forward to your comments below!