Select to view content in your preferred language

Allow tables to be stored into FeatureDataset

2527
12
04-11-2010 10:58 PM
Status: Closed
Labels (1)
NicolasPy
Deactivated User

Would be nice if tables could be stored into FeatureDatatset. Now, the only place to write them is the geodatabase root level... Some tables belong to a FeatureDataset logical theme and so have to be into it.

12 Comments
NicolasPy
'tables' means naturally 'standalone tables'...
NicolasPy
JoshWhite
Couldn't agree more.
DusanOstojic
 Also it would be nice to group tables somehow.. in some TablesDataset...
KATHERINEHADLER
I agree.  This would eliminate permissions issues.
NicolasPy
"If it has no geometry, it cannot participate in topological relationships. And if it cannot participate, it has no place being in a Feature Dataset (FD)." (dananrg )

i don't agree. Geodatabases (personnal, file or sde) works on DBMS theorys, including relation between tables and normalization (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization). Thus, a table has a place being in a fd...
TimLowrimore

I am going to make it simple because esri does not seem to listen to customers that have wanted this since the concept of Datasets was introduced.

s. t. o. r. e.
r. e. l. a. t. e. d.
t. a. b. l. e. s.
i. n.
d. a. t. a. s. e. t. s.
!!!

Thanks.
-Tim

DavidVelhartický

Often it would be helpful to be able to add non-geometry table to Feature Dataset.

Not only because of "using Feature Dataset as a folder" but setting of permissions too and so on.

Some of "why" ideas here:

https://community.esri.com/t5/data-management-questions/tables-in-feature-datasets/td-p/404570

SRK
by

Why is to such a fundamental thing to add? Either add folders oder let people add tables to feature datasets. When you have 3 tables and one featureclass all having relationship classes between each other you can really fast just give up using the Katalog view to find anything...

ShannonShields
Status changed to: Closed

Feature datasets are specific to storing spatial data that participates in a controller dataset. Non-spatial tables are not part controller datasets and therefore will not be part of feature datasets.

For more information on feature datasets and their intended use please see https://pro.arcgis.com/en/pro-app/latest/help/data/feature-datasets/feature-datasets-in-arcgis-pro.h....