Collections Alt-text

Question

Had a comment come across one of my collections, and this will probably be a recurring comment regarding 508 compliance, asking about alt-text for the story map thumbnails in collections. I looked at the settings for the images and did not see a place for alt-text.

I'm contemplating posting an idea but wanted to see first if this was already in the pipeline. Thanks.

oevans_storymaps · Answer

That's great that USFS is focusing on accessibility! Many government agencies at all levels, as well as commercial and non-profit organizations, are working to meet accessibility standards, and we agree it is very important.

Esri has has done a lot of work to make ArcGIS products both accessible themselves and capable of creating content that meets accessibility standards and guidelines. Here are some resources for learning more about accessibility and ArcGIS StoryMaps that might be helpful as you do more work in this area.

* Frequently asked questions—ArcGIS StoryMaps | Documentation
* Accessibility and supported languages—ArcGIS StoryMaps | Documentation
* Contains a link to the Accessibility Conformance Report for ArcGIS StoryMaps

* Getting started with accessible storytelling (arcgis.com)
* A detailed resource that covers color, typography, structure, and more

* Writing accessible ArcGIS StoryMaps content (esri.com)
* A practical guide to making stories accessible from the University of Minnesota GIS department

* Building an accessible product : our journey so far (esri.com)
* Overview of how accessibility is incorporated into the development of ArcGIS StoryMaps

In the case of the collection thumbnails, I think it's important to note that accessibility guidelines require an alt attribute for every image. However, images that serve a decorative purpose do not need author-provided alt text, which is why it isn't currently in our plans to add a way for authors to enter alt text for collection thumbnails. (One reference is here, but you can find this in many other places, including 508 guidelines here.)

The intended purpose of collection thumbnails is to make the overview page more engaging for sighted readers. But since each item has a title, which is read by screen readers, the images are considered decorative because the title conveys all the information needed for non-sighted readers to distinguish each item. If non-sighted readers also had to also listen to image alt text for each item on the overview page we feel this would make their experience needlessly complex.

From a technical perspective, as mentioned above, accessibility guidelines say that decorative images should have an empty alt tag in the HTML. This is something that ArcGIS StoryMaps does automatically for you. For example, you can see the empty alt tag on the collection item thumbnail in the screenshot, below.

I believe this should address your concern about the requirement for all images to have alt text, but let me know if you have additional questions.

Anonymous User · Answer

I work for the Federal government and there is a big push for 508 compliance. Every product we produce needs to meet accessibility standards. Images we use need to have alt-text for screen readers.

Even though 508 has been around for some time, our agency (Forest Service), has been really trying to implement 508 into everything we do. This is a conversation that is growing and will be talked about more as time goes on.

oevans_storymaps · Answer

Hi Bryan! Our assessment is that collection item thumbnails are decorative, so we do not currently have plans to add the ability for authors to attach alt text to them.

Is there a case where you'd consider the thumbnails not to be decorative that you can share?