Mike-
In order for CSV files to work properly, the coordinates need to be in decimal degrees instead of degrees, decimal minutes and instead of using N and W use the minus sign for latitudes west of the Prime meridian, or south of the equator.
For Example:
Your first coordinate
VCom1 N 39° 57.184' W 105° 01.311'
should read more like:
VCom1 39.953066 -105.02185
This should help.