Select to view content in your preferred language

What is the future of ArcCatalog in future Pro versions?

23122
81
02-10-2015 11:59 AM
RenatoSalvaleon
Frequent Contributor


Unless I missed it, there's several Administration features in current ArcCatalog that are not available in Pro, specially the ones for geodatabases, e.g., Manage and Administer which is slightly different for each type of data objects.

81 Replies
curtvprice
MVP Esteemed Contributor

We have quite a few USGS people still Workstation and 3x. Some kludgy workarounds are required to run with current Windows technology, but amazingly, you still can go back and run ArcEdit and Avenue code!

AndrewQuee
Frequent Contributor

...Even though ArcInfo Workstation "retired" at 10.2 I think, we still have users using it today. ...

You're not alone.

There was a GIS specialist job that was advertised here for a state agency recently and some of the core criteria were experience in managing spatial data/processing in ArcInfo Workstation and the ability to develop AML code.  This agency is not even at ArcGIS-level yet, let alone Pro.

LeoLadefian5
Frequent Contributor

Is there anyway to avoid having to connect to data sources every time you open a new project? It's ludicrous to think I have to do this every time I open a "mapdoc" or Project.

0 Kudos
Robert_LeClair
Esri Notable Contributor

Yes, create your own Project Template for Pro.

ThomasColson
MVP Frequent Contributor

It's important to note, that even with a project template, you cannot connect to the root of a drive letter, whether it's a network share, hard drive, or portable storage media. Not sure what the reasoning behind that restriction is. 

TylerSchwartz2
Frequent Contributor

@Robert

A Project Template will not only package whatever layers you have in your table of contents, but it will also package the data source as well (instead of just a layer that links to the source data).  

For instance, I have a custom basemap that I created with the Business Analyst USA national data, that I use as my basemap.  If I have that basemap included in my Project when I export the Project Template, it attempts to bundle my entire basemap dataset into the project template!  Changing the different settings in the Project Template pane does not make any difference.  It will always bundle whatever data you had loaded into the Project Template, instead of linking it (like it should)...  This shouldnt be happening (is it a bug?).  Ideally, the project template should only bundle the layer that links to the source data - not bundle the entire source dataset as part of the template!

Whereas in ArcMap, I can create a .mxd (as my template file) with the custom basemap already loaded, and can reuse that file over and over - the basemap data stays LINKED (obviously).  Now, in Pro, you cant do this with Project Templates (which is really too bad and reduces the functionality we had in ArcMap).  As a work around, I dont include my basemap in my Project Template, and instead have to manually load and configure my custom basemap every time I start a new project...  Cumbersome to say the least.

Also there is a bug with the Project Template that causes your Project Folder connections to have wrong paths after saving out a Project Template and re-loading it into a new Project.  You have to manually fix these every time you start a New Project using that Project Template.

Robert_LeClair
Esri Notable Contributor

Tyler - the Project Template bug you mention is NIM101431.  I haven't been able to find much about it to determine if it was resolved at Pro 1.4.

TylerSchwartz2
Frequent Contributor

Thanks, I will watch for this fix in upcoming releases. I only downloaded Pro 1.4 a few days ago and havent played around with the Project Templates since 1.3

0 Kudos
KevinHibma
Esri Regular Contributor

NIM101431 is marked as fixed -- I think in Pro 1.1 or 1.2.

I know for certain that its fixed in 1.3 and 1.4.

If you're still seeing the issue, then either its a different issue, or we didn't fix the particular case/workflow you're experiencing.

If you give it another try, and it looks to be a problem still, could you either provide your steps here or submit a tech support request?

TylerSchwartz2
Frequent Contributor

Thanks Kevin, is there a way I can see the bug report for NIM101431. I searched on ESRI support but it came up with nothing.  

I would like to see the bug report, so I can understand if it pertains specifically to the Project Folder path issue, or the Project Template data packaging issue.  This would be very helpful to see.

Our organization has a maintenance contract if that makes a difference. Thanks again.

0 Kudos