Splitting large polygons creates gaps and shifts boundaries

[AustinBartos]

Hi all,

I've been running into a very frustrating issue with splitting large polygons (~60,000 acres). Seemingly at random, splitting a polygon results in gaps at the split or a subtle shifting of one or both of the split polygons. I've tried interactive splitting, and splitting by feature by creating a split line feature class. I've also tried adjusting the XY resolution and tolerance to 10x and 100x the default with no success. GCS is NAD 1983. Is this a bug or is there another solution I'm not finding?

[SeaRM]

I'm sorry, but it wasn't clear for me what you tried to do and what the initial task is.

How do you need to split the polygons? Are there in the same feature class? What kind of result do you expect?

[RobertCao · Accepted solution]

Hello @AustinBartos ,

There is an existing software defect BUG-000165171 regarding the shifting problem which could be related to the issue you are seeing. Here is bug that I was referring to. I hope this will help.

Thanks 

Rob

[AustinBartos]

Thanks Rob - I'm looking forward to a fix for this! 🙂

[David_Lindsey]

@RobertCao- Thanks for providing this. Do you know if that same issue could be impacting other topology-related operations? For example, I'm using the Align Edge tool with a map topology and a sliver gap is getting introduced where there is literally no possibility of one getting generated by the end-user (I've tested this is Pro 3.2.x and now 3.3.0 with the same effect). If you don't have additional info, I am likely going to submit this to Esri Support as an additional bug.

[IslamOsama]

Have you found a solution? I'm facing the same issue.

[LaraOles1]

Has this been fixed??? This totally negates the reason for using topology!