Hi @EricRoper
Hope you're doing well. It looks like "Consolidation failed" points towards a potential incorrect path in your input data, that may not be represented by the traditional red exclamation point. A web map will fail to publish if a feature class's data source has been altered to point to a new feature dataset in the same file geodatabase. Please go through each of the sources in your map's Contents, and ensure they are all pointing to the correct data, and that adequate permissions are set for each.
Tip: You may be able to narrow down the erroneous layer(s) by moving half of your layers to a new Map, and attempting to publish. This will tell you which half of your data contains the issue. You can repeat the process to further narrow down the problem layer(s)
Best,
Taren
