The standard member roles that Esri sets up cannot be changed or deleted. Therefore I would like the default setting to be that members cannot publish their content publicly. A new, dedicated, member role could then be created to give certain members the right to publish content publicly.
In our organisation only administrators can publish data publicly. Members have to register a request with an end date and a person that will check the data (quality control) before they get their data published. The administrators can verify that no confidential data is shared publicly and that data is taken offline after the end date.
We see sharing data publicly as a serious process and we don't want members to inadvertently share their data publicly when all they wanted to do was share it with the organisation. We have covered this by creating custom member roles without the privilege to share publicly. But because the standard member roles cannot be deleted, it is still possible that a member might accidentally be assigned to a standard member role instead of our custom member role. Adjusting the default settings would add a layer of protection against data leaks.
Note: this applies to ArcGIS Enterprise as well as ArcGIS Online. I have therefore posted this in the Enterprise community too: https://community.esri.com/t5/arcgis-enterprise-ideas/privilege-to-publish-publicly-set-default-off/...
