topic Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools) in Water Resources Questions

Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

John_Herrera — Tue, 24 Oct 2023 19:56:28 GMT

What's the difference between using Fill in the Spatial Analyst Extension and Fill Sinks in the Arc Hydro Tools? When hydrologically conditioning a DEM, what is the preferred tool? Inspecting the Fill Sinks script, it appears that the script is calling the Fill tool in the Spatial Analyst Extension (fill_dem = arcpy.sa.Fill(input_dem, fill_threshold).

Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

DanPatterson — Tue, 24 Oct 2023 20:42:37 GMT

This may be of interest to you

Arc Hydro - Identifying and Managing Sinks.pdf (esri.com)

Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

John_Herrera — Tue, 24 Oct 2023 20:52:44 GMT

Thank you! That's pretty cool, a well known figure in the GIS community replied to my post 😀

Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

DanPatterson — Tue, 24 Oct 2023 21:08:00 GMT

Just trying to "Fill" you in 😁

Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

DeanDjokic — Wed, 25 Oct 2023 06:12:22 GMT

The key difference is that Arc Hydro fill allows you to specify "deranged" polygons as input. These areas will NOT be filled. So it is a different option than standard fill that can limit the fill by depth. Document that Dan pointed you to goes into details on how to identify and manage sinks if you choose to have them. Note that if you are going to do full terrain preprocessing (so you can use AH tools for watershed delineation etc.), you need to tweak the flow direction in sinks (described in that document as well).

And finally, if you are using Pro 3.0 and up, there are tools that allow you to do flow direction and accumulation without filling sinks. In general, it provides better results than using the fill approach.

Re: Fill (Spatial Analyst) vs Fill Sinks (Arc Hydro Tools)

John_Herrera — Thu, 26 Oct 2023 20:42:20 GMT

[bowing to my GIS sensei] Thank you, Dean! I greatly appreciate you droppin' that knowledge on me!