topic Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?! in Python Questions

arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_Management 999999 Error

ZacharyHart — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 14:53:16 GMT

I'm seeing some different behavior here in ArcGIS Pro.

In this particular case I'm using

arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_management(in_layer,out_layer)‍‍

[Curiously, this works in the python command window but fails in a script tool].

When I try

arcpy.management.SaveToLayerFile(in_layer, out_layer) ‍‍

in the python window with the same parameters the tool fails with an 000622 error. I tried to supply the other optional parameters but it still failed.

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

DanPatterson_Retired — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 16:47:42 GMT

Is ArcMap/ArcGIS Pro open or closed when you do this.

When you say the "python command window" which one?

When you sayt the "python window" the one that is built into *map/*pro?

maybe a 'console' in a python IDE, like the IPython console in Spyder?

can you specify what you used exactly as...

in_layer …. had you set your environments to work in a geodatabase? is *.map/*.pro open

out_layer …. was this a full path to a folder for a layer file (*.lyr or *.lyrx)

I suspect that the in_layer and/or the out_layer can't be found because of the above conditions

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Sun, 12 Dec 2021 07:04:49 GMT

Ah, yes...important clarifications. Sorry if i wasn't specific enough...I thought Esri was calling the 'python window' the built-in interface...well, at least that's what they called it in ArcMap. But yes: built-in interface in ArcGIS Pro...no console.

2 separate issues but I'll focus on your questions first.

If I run the the code from the 'python window' the layer file is exported just fine...within the script tool it fails with a 999999 error. One thing to keep in mind here is that these inputs are used elsewhere in the script tool just fine. But let me try to pare this down to what's relevant here.

#Import Modules
import arcpy, os

#Variables
Date = time.strftime("%m%d%Y")
OutputFolder = "D:\\TEMP" ##In the script tool this is exposed as a parameter and not hard-coded. 
LayerName = "SoilsMUID_" + Date + ".lyrx"
ExportLayer = os.path.join(OutputFolder, LayerName)

#Setup Map Document Info
aprx = arcpy.mp.ArcGISProject("CURRENT") ##In the script tool, this points to an aprx file using the full path.
map = aprx.listMaps("Soils")[0]
SoilsLyr = map.listLayers('SoilsMUID')[0] ##This layer's data source is a shapefile

#Export Layer File
arcpy.AddMessage("Exporting Layer File to {0}".format(ExportLayer))
arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_management(SoilsLyr, ExportLayer)‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍

In the script tool (if the SaveToLayerFile is commented out), the tool goes on to select the in_layer, zoom to it, and some other stuff and then a PDF is exported no problem.

FWIW, I also tried to create a feature layer from SoilsLyr and then pass that to SaveToLayerFile_management (unneeded but worth a try) and that fails as well.

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

DanPatterson_Retired — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 18:37:06 GMT

Layers can be referenced from within a project using the listLayers method on the Map class or in a layer file (.lyr or .lyrx) stored on disk using the listLayers method on the LayerFile class.

Based on that description, I would want to ensure that the SoilsLyr is indeed a full path for a file one disk. change line 15

arcpy.AddMessage("Soils layer {0}\nExporting Layer File to {1}".format(SoilsLyr, ExportLayer))

BTW, you don't need the {0} {1}… ie sequential numbers unless you intend to alter the order... but it is fine, unless you miss a number, then you have to debug … just keep then sequential is easiest

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Sun, 12 Dec 2021 07:04:52 GMT

Dan, I didn't expect that it will return a full path for a file on disk since I'm using the listLayers method for a layer within the map. I modified the message per your request and got the following from the script tool.

Again, if we comment out the SaveToLayerFile the script goes on to use SoilsLyr for several other things just fine so it sure seems the script has access to that as an input just fine?

arcpy.SelectLayerByAttribute_management(SoilsLyr, "NEW_SELECTION")
mf.zoomToAllLayers(True,True)
arcpy.SelectLayerByAttribute_management(SoilsLyr, "CLEAR_SELECTION")
mf.camera.setExtent(mf.getLayerExtent(SoilsLyr,True, True))‍‍‍‍

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

DarrenWiens2 — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 19:12:18 GMT

Can you humor me by trying to save to hardcoded:

ExportLayer = r'D:\TEMP\SoilsMUID_01172019.lyrx'

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 19:18:11 GMT

I like your thinking in eliminating that, but that also failed with a 999999 error

(Curiously, looking up a 999999 error I expected it to say "This is the most informative error code ever!"...sadly it did not).

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 20:01:28 GMT

Dan Patterson‌ I didn't expect this thread to morph like this so I should probably rename the title.

I'm still curious what the difference between

arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

DanPatterson_Retired — Thu, 17 Jan 2019 21:35:09 GMT

I would have to look up the reason... someone posted it recently, but the former is 'more pythonic' in that conforms to the way most python packages work

package, module function

ie numpy linalg lstsq …

sometimes (so don't use arcpy as a good example) this represents a folder structure but more generally a namespace structure.

It is usually not that simple but I know that the least squares function is in the linear algrebra section of the numpy module

numpy doesn't use the numpy.(tool)_package approach... I think esri modified that namespace useage to make it easier for gis peeps.

I prefer to think of arctools in this context arcpy.toolbox.tool with arcpy being a convenience to access tools in the toolbox namespace

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Fri, 18 Jan 2019 13:11:40 GMT

Dan Patterson‌ Dan, that makes perfect sense!

So, now I'm wondering why (regardless of the script tool) the tool works one way but not the other in Pro? I don't know if that's a bug or hints at one, or possibly that there is indeed something wrong with the inputs since

arcpy.management.SaveToLayerFileReturns a 000622 error.

Also, I failed to answer one of Dan's original questions which was if the map project was open. When I run the code from the python window setting the aprx to 'CURRENT' it works fine. However...when I run the code in the python window from another map project and set the aprx to the full file path of the closed project, then I get the same error as in my script tool! So that's something there.

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

JoshuaBixby — Sun, 12 Dec 2021 07:04:54 GMT

I'm still curious what the difference between arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management

Both point back to the same compiled code. There should not be a difference in how they handle the inputs. If there is a difference, it is likely a bug.

>>> import arcpy
>>> 
>>> # both reference same memory location
>>> arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_management
<function SaveToLayerFile at 0x7f9237a9bb70>
>>> arcpy.management.SaveToLayerFile
<function SaveToLayerFile at 0x7f9237a9bb70>
>>> 
>>> # so both have same Python id
>>> id(arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_management)
140265975823216
>>> id(arcpy.management.SaveToLayerFile)
140265975823216
>>> 
‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍

Re: arcpy.mangement.{tool} vs arcpy.{tool}_management What's the difference?!

ZacharyHart — Fri, 18 Jan 2019 18:19:16 GMT

Joshua Bixby‌ this is very helpful from a diagnostic perspective. Thanks a bunch!

Re: arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_Management 999999 Error

ZacharyHart — Sun, 12 Dec 2021 07:04:57 GMT

Joshua Bixby‌ Dan Patterson‌ Darren Wiens‌

Hi everyone, I wanted to thank you for your help and also give you a bit of an update. Here's what I know to date:

Today Esri Support verified there was a bug for this tool.
BUG ID: BUG-000117445
Synopsis: The Save To Layer File management tool fails and returns Error 999999 when run from the Python IDLE window in ArcGIS Pro.
Status: New
We confirmed that this tool also fails when used in a script tool
The current ArcGIS Pro documentation is still outdated and referencing working with .lyr files.
I was able to find a workaround using 'saveACopy' as part of the arcpy mapping module layer class.
Here is a quick example:

#Import Modules
import arcpy, os

#Variables
Date = time.strftime("%m%d%Y")
OutputFolder = "D:\\TEMP"
LayerName = "SoilsMUID_" + Date + ".lyrx"
ExportLayer = os.path.join(OutputFolder, LayerName)

#Setup Map Document Info
aprx = arcpy.mp.ArcGISProject("Path to your aprx file")
map = aprx.listMaps("Soils")[0]
SoilsLyr = map.listLayers('SoilsMUID')[0] ##This layer's data source is a shapefile

#Export Layer File
arcpy.AddMessage("Exporting Layer File to {0}".format(ExportLayer))
SoilsLyr.saveACopy(ExportLayer)‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍

Re: arcpy.SaveToLayerFile_Management 999999 Error

JoshuaBixby — Thu, 24 Jan 2019 21:23:00 GMT

Thanks for the update, this is useful not just to those who commented here, but anyone in the future who finds this thread.