topic Re: Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image in Data Management Questions

Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image

ToddKesselring1 — Mon, 23 Jan 2012 12:08:04 GMT

I used the Focal Statistics tool in the Neighborhood toolbox out of the Spatial Analyst tools and created a STD image from a 16 bit, unsigned integer TIFF image. The result was a 32 bit floating point image TIFF. My question is why did it change the pixel type and pixel depth? Is there a way to control this in the output or is the increased pixel depth actually desirable?

Re: Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image

ChrisBater — Mon, 23 Jan 2012 13:40:51 GMT

I imagine because calculating standard deviation on a bunch of integers still requires a floating point number for maximum precision. For example the standard deviation of [1,2,2,2] is 0.5. You could always run the integer (INT) tool on the output standard deviation raster to convert back.

Chris

Re: Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image

ToddKesselring1 — Mon, 23 Jan 2012 16:40:47 GMT

I imagine because calculating standard deviation on a bunch of integers still requires a floating point number for maximum precision. For example the standard deviation of [1,2,2,2] is 0.5. You could always run the integer (INT) tool on the output standard deviation raster to convert back.

Chris

Good point, Chris. I guess it depends on how much precision I need. I will need to look at some neighboring values and see if it would work with less precision. I am glad you pointed out the INT tool. Thanks!

Todd

Re: Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image

JeffreyEvans — Mon, 23 Jan 2012 19:34:31 GMT

It is not a matter of precision in the way your are thinking. The values after the decimal are important and just truncating them can bias how a given statistical moment represents the distribution function. As such, be careful truncating floating point values using Int. If you want a 16-bit image you could do something like.

Int(FocalStatistics(raster,NbrRectangle(3,3,MAP), "STD")*1000)

Re: Standard deviation image created from 16 bit raster image is a 32 bit image

ToddKesselring1 — Wed, 01 Feb 2012 13:32:16 GMT

Jeffrey,

Thanks for the input. Yes, even though the size seems excessive the extra information may prove useful. I am using the standard deviation with the original brightness as a 2 band stacked image for supervised classification. The values past the decimal may be decisive in assigning pixels to classes.

Todd