topic Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset in Data Management Questions

ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

RoderickPearson — Mon, 10 Jul 2023 15:27:10 GMT

I am using ArcGIS World Geocoding Service to Geocode a CSV file of 64,036 addresses. I set the geocoding options to

Minimum candidate score: 70

Minimum match score: 75

The results of the geocoding process had:

Matched: 63,453 addresses
Tied: 583 addresses

However, when I attempted to replicate the process and geocode the table again under the same parameters I received slightly different results.

The results of second geocoding process had:

Matched: 63,359 addresses
Tied: 677 addresses

I am confused as to why I received two different results using ArcGIS World Geocoding Service when using the same dataset and geocoding parameters, I would greatly appreciate any help or insight as to why I received two different results for the process.

Thanks, Roderick

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

ShanaBritt — Mon, 24 Jul 2023 05:28:49 GMT

@RoderickPearson Which application were you using when you geocoded your table with the ArcGIS World Geocoding Service when you encountered the inconsistent behavior?

-Shana

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

RoderickPearson — Tue, 25 Jul 2023 10:27:50 GMT

I was using ArcMap version 10.5 when I geocoded my table with the ArcGIS World Geocoding Service when I encountered this problem. I thought the issue was because I was using a slightly older version of ArcMap however I could not find any information on this problem for that version of ArcMap specifically.

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

ShanaBritt — Tue, 25 Jul 2023 18:14:55 GMT

Are you still using ArcMap 10.5 or are continuing to get the same inconsistent behavior when using the ArcGIS World Geocoding Service? Does your organization have plans to move to ArcGIS Pro?

-Shana

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

RoderickPearson — Wed, 26 Jul 2023 05:39:16 GMT

I am still using ArcMap 10.5 and when I attempt to geocode the table again I get the following results again.

Matched: 63,359 addresses
Tied: 677 addresses

I am now consistently getting this result in ArcMap whenever I geocode the table of addresses again however, I am still unsure at to how I received the original results of:

Matched: 63,453 addresses
Tied: 583 addresses

I checked the geocoding settings however I have kept them the same when I geocoded the table. So I'm not sure whether that is the reason why the results were slightly different. My University does provide access to ArcGIS Pro however, when I geocode the table the results I receive in ArcGIS Pro are also slightly different.

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

ShanaBritt — Wed, 26 Jul 2023 06:23:44 GMT

Which version of ArcGIS Pro is used by your University? Are you saving the geocode result out to a shapefile or geodatabase? Are you saving the geocode results to your local machine or network location?

-Shana

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

RoderickPearson — Wed, 26 Jul 2023 12:27:27 GMT

Currently we are using ArcGIS Pro version 2.8 and I'm currently saving the geocode results as a shapefile to my local machine

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

ShanaBritt — Thu, 27 Jul 2023 18:25:21 GMT

Do you get the same behavior when you save the output to a file geodatabase?

Re: ArcGIS World Geocoding Service gives different results for the same dataset

RoderickPearson — Wed, 02 Aug 2023 13:25:15 GMT

Yes, even when I output the file to a geodatabase I still get different results for geocoding than what I originally got