topic Re: VB6 App to esriAddIn: How to package custom OCXes in ArcObjects SDK Questions

VB6 App to esriAddIn: How to package custom OCXes

MeToo — Tue, 21 Dec 2010 00:29:36 GMT

Hello everyone:

I have migrated a large VB6 ArcGIS 9.x application to VB.NET ArcGIS 10 add-in. It uses a couple of VB6 OCXes. Everything works fine on my development PC but when I start distributing the add-in, the target PC encounters COMexceptions. They go away if I register the OCXes manually on the target PC.

What's the recommended 'best practice' methodology for distributing and, if necessary, registering the OCXes on target PCs when releasing ArcGIS Desktop extensions as add-ins?

I think that I could create an installation package (with InstallShield for ex.) that would register the OCXes and automatically start the esriaddin file. It seems to defy the simplicity of end-users double-clicking on the esriaddin file.

Thanks

Re: VB6 App to esriAddIn: How to package custom OCXes

RichardWatson — Wed, 22 Dec 2010 18:04:58 GMT

If you use COM components then you have to register them because the registry is fundamental to how COM works.

IMHO, the point of add-ins is to move away from COM thus enabling XCopy deployment.

COM is incompatible with XCopy deployment.

Re: VB6 App to esriAddIn: How to package custom OCXes

MeToo — Thu, 23 Dec 2010 09:45:42 GMT

Thanks Richard.

What would prevent one from packaging the esriaddin and OCX/dependencies with InstallShield (for ex.), and having the latter "Start.exe theEsriAddIn" at the end of the installation? Would that work? The idea/hope would be that when the software is updated, the dependencies (that don't change) would already be on the end-user PCs and only the esriaddin would be needed and could be installed on a double-click.

I remember reading several months ago a couple of words (literally) in the esriaddin documentation that several libraries could be specified in the esriaddin Config.XML <Library=myProject.dll> tag. Could anybody give me an example of when that would be used?

Thanks

Re: VB6 App to esriAddIn: How to package custom OCXes

RichardWatson — Thu, 23 Dec 2010 11:55:35 GMT

You also need to think about how you are going to handle uninstall.