topic Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents in ArcGIS Spatial Analyst Questions

Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

MichaelMarkieta — Tue, 15 Feb 2011 18:31:08 GMT

I am having trouble adding multiple rasters to create an overal classifications raster.

Currently, I have 3 criteria variables (polygons), which have been converted from vector to raster. Each raster represents a different extent of spatial coverage on my map (eg, highways, land usage, pop density by Census Tract... I am creating a human influence index)

I will use a simplified grid example, such as those used in the ArcMap help/resources.

Below you will see the addition (summation) of 3 raster grids, with the output that I am currently experiencing. This is NOT what I would like. (grey = nodata)

Here is an example of what I would like to happen.

I've spent too much time trying to figure this out. I hope someone can steer me to the right tool or option/setting?

Note: I am using ArcMap 10

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

PatrickTaurman — Tue, 15 Feb 2011 20:29:29 GMT

What you could do is use a con(isnull([raster]), 0, [raster]) statement in the Raster Calculator which will change all your NoData pixels to 0 allowing the rasters to be added together. That's assuming you don't have 0 as a pixel value.

If you do have 0 as a valid pixel value, add 1 to each raster using the Plus tool, run the Con(isnull) statement (to change NoData to zero), add them all together, reclassify so that anything marked 0 is NoData, and then subtract 3.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

MichaelMarkieta — Tue, 15 Feb 2011 21:07:09 GMT

I may have asked the question poorly by using the wrong terms and explanation. This is the first time I have had to ask for help so please bear with me. I am usually not this needy...

I think I may have misinterpreted NODATA for "not a part of the raster". But in fact, nodata means there is a cell which is part of that raster grid, but it has nodata associated with it.

Hopefully this makes more sense...

What you can picture this as is two polygon shape files that have been converted to raster. One raster represents population density (values=4, 7, 10) and the other represents a highway (value=10). The rasters have cells which coincide in space, as well as cells that do not coincide. I would like to create a new raster that has a summation of values for each cell, whether or not every raster has data for every particular cell.

As you can see, the data from the rasters where the cells do not "overlay" each other is tossed from the calculation.

How can I work around this?

To get this:

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

MichaelMarkieta — Tue, 15 Feb 2011 21:38:45 GMT

I think I may have found the right tool within spatial analyst.

By utilizing Cell Statistics with the ignore NoData box CHECKED, I am able to "SUM" and produce a new raster with what I believe I can use for my "Human Influence Index" (human footprint).

If there is a better way to go about this, please let me know. Thank you for your attention voldune.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

davidquiros — Wed, 09 Mar 2011 04:07:52 GMT

I have been searching for hours how to solve this same problem. I found some tutorials online that seem to work, but not for ArcGIS 10.

I've tried using mosaics, the raster calculator, clipping, etc. I just tried cells statistics, and it seems that the ignore no data needs to be UNCHECKED. However, the result is still the same as when I use the raster calculator.

If the spatial extent of ALL/BOTH raster files do not span the distance, the program still takes the intersection, not the union, of the raster files.

Anybody have any advice?

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

profchamberlain — Thu, 23 Feb 2012 11:16:38 GMT

I also need to mosaic multiple rasters together, by summing the values when more than one raster has a value for a given location. I searched various options online, however, I am not able to find something that works for my situation.

Here is what I am dealing with:

[ATTACH=CONFIG]12156[/ATTACH]

In this image, each blue box represents a different floating point raster. I need to mosaic all rasters into a single result, where the overlapping areas are summed values. Normally, it would be easy to modify the files to ensure that all the extents are the same, then convert NoData to zero, and Add.

There are two problems with this:

given the extent and resolution, each raster would need to be roughly 50GB in size (sure I could compress but it won't save that much).

I have about 500 rasters

Did any of you manage to find a solution?

Thanks for the help!

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

deleted-user-IR249IovB3CN — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 19:41:49 GMT

Has anyone solved this? It appears to have been a long running problem with no solid solution.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

profchamberlain — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 19:58:58 GMT

I have been working with ESRI on a fix for sometime, and it appears that they have found a solution. The fix is to use Cell Statistics, ensuring that NoData is not considered in the calculation. As many people may have discovered, Cell Statistics really only creates a pseudo-intersection of values. In order to correct the problem, one needs to create a raster with the value of zero, which embodies the full spatial extent of all rasters for which the "merging" needs to happen. Then, that raster, and all others need to be included in the Cell Statistics tool, using the option Sum values.

It does work, but it can also be quite slow depending upon size. If others have similar problems and find that this solves the problem, please report your successes/issues here, so we can all benefit!

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

SteveLynch — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 21:13:11 GMT

Brent

Are you talking about the enhancement that went into ArcGIS10 which was released in 2011?

See
http://help.arcgis.com/en/arcgisdesktop/10.0/help/index.html#/Cell_Statistics/009z0000007q000000/

-Steve

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

profchamberlain — Mon, 16 Apr 2012 21:18:11 GMT

Precisely! (Apologies if you do not have that version)

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

deleted-user-IR249IovB3CN — Tue, 17 Apr 2012 14:02:30 GMT

The method of using Cell Statistics with a raster of values = 0 covering the entire analysis extent worked, as described above. I had issues initially with an inaccurate extent so I set some environmental parameters of the tool. They were: Set output coordinate system, set the processing extent "union of Inputs", set the 0 raster as my snap raster, and in Raster Analysis settings I set the cell size and mask to the 0 raster. After doing this the tool worked. ESRI, if your listening, a blog post would be useful to share this process/fix with the greater community.

Thank you for your help.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

AndrewKamerosky — Fri, 27 Jul 2012 14:51:35 GMT

Ok, I am having no luck in following what y'all have done. I have the same task, multiple (100+) rasters of different extents and most not overlapping (But in the same area) that I am simply trying to sum the values (0,1). The map is going to show how many times a given cell was "treated". All the rasters have had the noData changed to 0 (Using the reclassify tool, a lot easier than raster math).

So I tried to do the cell statistics. The first attempt started with the creation of a basemap of pixel values of 0, which covers all the other cell locations. I then entered a subset of maps (for the one year) that included the basemap. I set it to run "sum". I then set the environment settings as mattlove described (set spatial, snap raster, raster analysis settings to the basemap and chose untion of inputs). But I still get "Invalid Output Extent". When I set the Processing Extent to the basemap, it runs but the output is blank/corrupted/I have no idea why there's no data.

What've done, just so I can get this rolling while someone else can help me figure out whats going wrong, is mosaic the pieces to the basemap (Using Mosaic to Net Raster). Then I can use the Cell Statistics tool to sum all the maps now that they are all the same size. This process is not time efficent at all, I've tried building a model to run this but that hasn't worked out yet.

Please tell me ESRI has created a tool that does this or help me figure out what I'm doing wrong with Cell Statistics that it won't cooperate.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

deleted-user-IR249IovB3CN — Sat, 15 Apr 2017 15:28:26 GMT

Stumbled across this issue again. Solution: Create a continuous raster with value = 0. Run Cell statistics with all desired rasters, including the continuous raster. The Overlay Statistic = "Sum". Be sure to set "processing extent" in environment settings to "Union of Inputs".

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

MaryCoburn1 — Fri, 09 Jun 2017 15:02:21 GMT

In the environment settings (at the bottom of raster calculator) set the processing extent to Union of Inputs.

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

PhillipBurrows — Wed, 28 Nov 2018 02:32:22 GMT

Easy fix: use Cell Statistics tool. Select SUM as your 'Overlay Statistic' and check the Ignore NoData in calculations box

Re: Add (SUM) Multiple Rasters of different extents

ChristofJörg — Fri, 23 Dec 2022 07:00:37 GMT

This was exactly what I was looking for, thank you so much!