CancellationToken parameter on RouteTask methods (e.g. SolveRouteAsync)?

DavidSchuster — Wed, 08 Mar 2023 16:16:37 GMT

Hello,

We have an .NET Framework application that uses the ArcGIS Maps SDK for .NET version 200.0. The app includes functionality for routing/navigation.

We would like for the user to be able to cancel the route calculation (for example, if it's taking too long, etc). In the tasked-based async pattern in .NET (which we are using in our app), the recommendation is to support a CancellationToken parameter on asynchronous methods so that long running tasks can be cancelled if necessary.

Would it be possible to add the CancellationToken parameter to the RouteTask methods in a future release of the ArcGIS Maps SDK?

Do you have any recommendations on how best to handle cancellation in the meantime? I was thinking of either letting the route solve continue to completion and then throwing away the result, or perhaps running the route solve in a separate thread and stopping that thread upon cancellation (which I'm concerned might lead to resource leaks).

Thank you!

David

Re: CancellationToken parameter on RouteTask methods (e.g. SolveRouteAsync)?

dotMorten_esri — Mon, 13 Mar 2023 23:13:59 GMT

For now you can just throw away the result. Most of the work is done server-side, and once the request is fired off, you can't really stop the server from doing the processing. You'd only save the download of the response, which is a minimal overhead in the grand total.

topic CancellationToken parameter on RouteTask methods (e.g. SolveRouteAsync)? in .NET Maps SDK Questions

CancellationToken parameter on RouteTask methods (e.g. SolveRouteAsync)?

Re: CancellationToken parameter on RouteTask methods (e.g. SolveRouteAsync)?