topic Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down in ArcGIS Pro Questions

Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Mon, 20 Apr 2020 18:53:31 GMT

I am creating a parking map and for each space I have inserted a point feature, within that attribute tble, I would like to have a field of TYPE which indicates what kind of parking (ada, gen, res, etc) I have gone through all the steps of creating domains and fields however, when I create a new field for the point attribute table, the value does not show up a drop down of the options I entered. I am completely lost! I have attached screenshots. Thank you!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

Katie_Clark — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 12:04:52 GMT

Is your PARKING_SPACE_ASSIGN point layer a shapefile, or a feature class within a geodatabase? Domains are not supported with shapefiles. You should see a Domain column within the fields table where you can assign a domain to a specific field.

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 13:23:46 GMT

Katherine Clark,

I was able to get it working by doing what you said, I turned my shapefile into a feature class and that worked. However, the domain description is what shows in the drop down not the code. I have read that there is a way to switch the display for that, but I can not find it using ArcGIS Pro 2.5. Any suggestions?

Thank you so much for your help!!

Dawn

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

Katie_Clark — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 13:54:18 GMT

In this case, is there a reason that you would want the code displayed instead of the description? I like to think of the Code like a field name, and the Description like a field alias, so normally that's what you would want displayed in the dropdown.

Like you, I found this article about changing the settings to display the code in ArcMap, but I am also not finding this same functionality in ArcGIS Pro. It would be interesting to know if this is planned for a future release, or if we're both just missing something!

In the meantime, if you really want your dropdown to display (for example) "RES" instead of "Reserved Assigned Parking", you can just put RES in the description field.

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

Katie_Clark — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 13:58:42 GMT

I spoke too soon....I did find this post that explains some (somewhat) newer features that were released with version 2.2

Turning off Coded Domain Value Display in ArcGIS Pro

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 14:57:29 GMT

That was the same article I had found!

Well, since this is my first time making a map like this, there are probably things I am doing that might not make sense to lol. Basically, I want the code to show for easier reading such as (ADA, RES, GOV, etc) instead of the whole description of the code. I suppose I could put the acronyms in the description, but it just seems to be backwards.

Also, I did try that "Show domain and subtype descriptions" option, however, it does not keep it as a drop down which doesn't make any sense. (see screenshots)

Thanks again!!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

Katie_Clark — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 15:11:32 GMT

Hmmm.....good catch! So with "Show Domain and Subtype Descriptions" unchecked, it displays the code in the attribute table as expected, but this setting does not apply to the dropdown when editing the attributes of a feature.

I would maybe add this comment to the Idea page I linked to, especially since it says "partially implemented". Might be something they would consider!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Tue, 21 Apr 2020 15:18:46 GMT

Awesome, I will do that!

Thanks, Katherine!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

KoryKramer — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 15:10:23 GMT

I believe that you may be running into BUG-000116316: Unable to view the domain assigned to a field if swi.. Please visit that page and Subscribe which will set you up for notifications and also increment the count of affected customers.

Thank you!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

KoryKramer — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 15:41:21 GMT

Also, Dawn Young‌ I made a quick demo of how using the Attributes Pane is a good workaround. See it here: Domain Code in Attribute Table Dropdown

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 16:10:51 GMT

Oh wow! Thanks, Kory Kramer‌!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 16:15:38 GMT

After watching your demo, I must have to have that bug. Thanks again, that was super helpful.

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 16:30:07 GMT

Kory Kramer‌,

Would you have an idea why when I change/update domain codes and/or descriptions, it does not update in attribute table? For example: I changed the 'perpendicular' CODE from "P" to "PERP" and it stayed as "P" in the attribute table.

I am sure to save any changes.

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

KoryKramer — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 16:41:17 GMT

Do you mean that you have P values in your attribute table, and then you update the domain code to PERP and existing values aren't updated? This would be expected. Existing values would need to be calculated to update them to PERP.

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

DawnYoung — Wed, 22 Apr 2020 17:20:09 GMT

Oh I see. Yes, after I changed the code value, I did calculate field and it updated them. Thank you!

Re: Trying to apply drop-down domain to attribute table, but it is not showing up on the table as a drop down

MirandaHancock — Thu, 13 Aug 2020 15:37:05 GMT

Thanks for the video! Do you know if this bug is associated to feature classes on SDE only? I hadn't had this problem until I moved my data into an SDE environment.