idea Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology in ArcGIS Online Ideas

Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

deleted-user-TRj-mR_qEmwV — Wed, 06 Mar 2019 18:46:54 GMT

That or allow for Style Symbology Arcade Expressions access the other arcade expressions in the pop-ups.

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

Amanda__Huber — Fri, 21 Jun 2019 14:45:41 GMT

ArcGIS Online‌ Any updates for when this functionality will be available?

Eager to use Arcade symbology from Feature Sets for a current project!

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

Amanda__Huber — Fri, 21 Jun 2019 23:01:21 GMT

Update: In case anyone else stumbles across this thread.

According to Esri it doesn't sound like this will be implemented in the next release of AGOL on June 25th, 2019: https://twitter.com/Huber099/status/1142196677320855553?s=20

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

RyanAglietti — Fri, 12 Feb 2021 20:01:39 GMT

I love that I can include attributes from other layers in the popup, but I would really like to be able to symbolize using it too!

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

WillYoung — Thu, 28 Oct 2021 14:18:38 GMT

Definitely keen to see this implemented. If only recently started using FeatureSet in my expressions, it is super useful so a shame it is limited.

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

VincentTanniere — Fri, 03 Feb 2023 08:32:53 GMT

+1 !

I really need this too. I was happy to obtain data from an another Layer in my pop up with FeatureSetbyName or FeatureSetbyID, but really disapointed to see that it doesn't work for style...

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

kawakawa4 — Wed, 03 May 2023 21:19:22 GMT

Yes please, this would be really useful!

An example of where this would be useful: I have points symbolised as pie charts and I want the pie chart to show the sum of all values from the join table related to that that point. Currently with a join view, I get several pie charts on top of each other. Or similarly, I would like the size of a point symbol to change according to the sum of all values from the join table related to that that point. Currently with a join view, I get several separate points on top of each other.

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

DaveSivertsenz — Mon, 22 May 2023 21:58:13 GMT

Feature class with related tables gives us a clean, logical structure. Unfortunately, to symbolize maps based on values calculated from multiple fields in a related table, we either duplicate fields in feature class and table, and add code to sync values, or break up the proper relational structure of our attributes.

Use case: 1:N relate, only use most recent value. Use most recent inspection date, and inspection interval, and current date, to symbolize features needing inspection in the coming year.

I imagine there may be performance issues with this request: a related popup is singular, vs calculated symbology for everything displayed - but sometimes the symbology is worth the wait, and the mapmaker can judge whether to employ it.

Re: Allow FeatureSet Functions to be Accessed in Arcade Expressions for Style Symbology

JordanHeiman — Fri, 16 Aug 2024 19:07:04 GMT

This would be a great feature to have and I still don't see it implemented unless I'm missing something.

Any one know any work arounds in the mean time? I don't really want to make a joined layer either because I have done that for other layers and that seems to take away my ability to edit the original layer if I need to beyond adding and editing data points