topic Re: Configuring a reverse proxy with ArcGIS Enterprise: same url for Portal and Server supported? in ArcGIS Enterprise Questions

Configuring a reverse proxy with ArcGIS Enterprise: same url for Portal and Server supported?

Jay_Gregory — Sun, 27 Feb 2022 20:55:15 GMT

I have inherited an ArcGIS Enterprise 10.9 instance - it has been configured with a reverse proxy instead of ArcGIS WebAdaptor. Both the Portal AND Server have been placed under the same URL - https://arcgis.mydomain.com/arcgis.

So for example going to Portal homepage is https://arcgis.mydomain.com/arcgis/home and going to Server REST endpoint is https://arcgis.mydomain.com/arcgis/rest/services.

I know this URL structure (using the same context for Portal and Server) is not supported using WebAdaptor, but I have not been able to figure out if its supported with a reverse proxy. I have poked around a little and haven't noticed any big issues and nothing seems broken but the site isn't heavily utilized yet either.

My questions are:

1. Is this setup valid / supported?

2. If not, what potential issues can it cause. i.e. where can I look for and validate problems.

3. If so, what other Enterprise related configurations are necessary - WebContextURL settings and the like?

Thx

Re: Configuring a reverse proxy with ArcGIS Enterprise: same url for Portal and Server supported?

Scott_Tansley — Sun, 27 Feb 2022 23:09:36 GMT

have you had a good read of this:

Integrate your portal with a reverse proxy or load balancer—Portal for ArcGIS | Documentation for ArcGIS Enterprise

and

Configure a reverse proxy server with ArcGIS Server—ArcGIS Server | Documentation for ArcGIS Enterprise

The rules seem to depend on which Reverse Proxy you're using and it's capability. You haven't mentioned which proxy so it's hard to be a bit more specific. If this was a manual build of Enterprise, rather than from a builder, then I'd consider trying to push Web Adaptors in if you haven't created content. It's a cleaner build and eminently more supportable (simple) in my opinion.

Re: Configuring a reverse proxy with ArcGIS Enterprise: same url for Portal and Server supported?

Jay_Gregory — Mon, 28 Feb 2022 14:38:30 GMT

Thanks - I had read through but since I'm not a load balancer expert I might have not read as thoroughly 🙂

So the only mention I could find is in the Portal section:

"When not using the ArcGIS Web Adaptor, the default context (/arcgis) must be used for the site. When integrating multiple Portal for ArcGIS and ArcGIS Server sites on the same layer 3/4 load balancer, a unique DNS record should be used for each site and Server Name Identification (SNI) used to route traffic to the appropriate back-end targets."

So what I can take away from this is if we're using a layer 7 load balancer, using the same context is supported - it is not supported with a layer 3/4 load balancer. Still don't quite understand the implications but good to know. Wish this was stated more explicitly somewhere, and cross referenced in the Server section as well.

I agree with WebAdaptor - I'm am much more comfortable in that environment, especially with HA or multi-node sites. Unfortunately at this point it is out of my control somewhat - we're using AWS and I think a ALB is easier for IT to maintain than Apache w/ 3rd part (i.e. esri) app installed.