topic Re: Map Service and Image Service in ArcGIS Enterprise Questions

Map Service and Image Service

FatinRimawi — Sun, 19 Mar 2017 10:35:43 GMT

I have an orthophoto, and i want to publish it.

Is it much better to publish it as map service or image service?

what is the difference between them?

what is the advantages/disadvantages for each type?

Which type has better caching ?

Thank you.

Best,

Fatin

Re: Map Service and Image Service

JayantaPoddar — Sun, 19 Mar 2017 10:56:02 GMT

A very good blog on this topic Imagery in Web applications: Should I use a cached map service or an image service?

If you want to retain the properties of an image (like pixel values, image enhancement, etc.), you need to publish the image as a image service. If it is just for visualization purpose, you might like to go for Map Service.

Caching will improve the rendering for both Map as well as image service. It is advisable to cache, if the map/image service don't change often.

Re: Map Service and Image Service

FatinRimawi — Sun, 19 Mar 2017 11:04:16 GMT

Thank you Jayanta.

Best,

Fatin

Re: Map Service and Image Service

RebeccaStrauch__GISP — Mon, 20 Mar 2017 22:17:29 GMT

To add to that, Image Server (or Image Server extension pre 10.5), is an additional license, so that may have to be taken into consideration.

However, even if you end up caching, in my tests, caching of an image service is much faster (~1/8 the time) than caching a map service. Dropping a 8 week cache job to ~10 days, while adding 5 more scales makes it pay for itself, in my opinion. Plus, the Image Server gives you the option to do either.

re: viewing as a basemap. If using a cached service, you will be limited to those scales when creating a web map (ArcMap will interpolate between cache levels/scales). This can work to your advantage if you need to control how users are viewing the maps, but can work against you if you do not have enough scale levels.

These are just my opinions. Results may vary.

Re: Map Service and Image Service

FatinRimawi — Tue, 21 Mar 2017 11:34:58 GMT

Thank you Rebecca for your replay, i really appreciated that.

Re: Map Service and Image Service

AndrewQuee — Tue, 16 Oct 2018 05:40:33 GMT

Thanks, very helpful. Link is now dead, new one appears to be Imagery in Web applications: Should I use a cached map service or an image service?

Re: Map Service and Image Service

LisaPierce1 — Wed, 15 Dec 2021 19:11:50 GMT

Hello _ I am trying to better understand if an image service includes the pixel values , it seems it cannot be used as a raster data model? Other than obtaining the actual raster feature dataset, is there any other way to extract part of a larger image service to use in a model ? I am still unclear with the new "raster" format definition, which is different than a "GRID" raster dataset?

Re: Map Service and Image Service

LisaPierce1 — Wed, 15 Dec 2021 19:12:07 GMT

Re: Map Service and Image Service

ErwanC — Mon, 23 May 2022 10:52:45 GMT

With Mapservice you can use "resampling image" for zooming higher than cache levels. With image service not yet in 10.8.1.