topic Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services in ArcGIS Enterprise Questions

Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

BehrouzHosseini — Tue, 04 Jul 2017 20:47:50 GMT

I have published a Feature Service on our ArcGIS Server 10.4.1 and in support section of the Feature Service URL I am seeing that the

ApplyEdits With Global Ids: false

can you please let me know why this is false? and how can I update it to True?

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

JakeSkinner — Wed, 05 Jul 2017 12:17:16 GMT

Hi Bengi,

From the help:

ArcGIS REST API

supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds will be true if the layer supports applying edits where globalid values provided by the client are used. In order for supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds to be true, layers must have a globalid column and have isDataVersioned as false. Layers with hasAttachments as true additionally require attachments with globalids and attachments related to features via the features globalid.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

GIS_Spellblade — Fri, 08 Sep 2017 21:03:49 GMT

I'm having issues with this setting as well.

I've launched a feature service with a point layer and two related tables from a file geodatabase in ArcMap via ArcGIS Online

The relationships are based on the globalid and the origin is set to the parent (point) layer

I allowed all operations in the feature access tab

After the service is launched when I look at the JSON from the feature service it shows that the apply global edits is set to false:

"supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds" : false,    "editorTrackingInfo" : {     "enableEditorTracking" : false,      "enableOwnershipAccessControl" : false,      "allowOthersToQuery" : true,      "allowOthersToUpdate" : true,      "allowOthersToDelete" : false,      "allowAnonymousToUpdate" : true,      "allowAnonymousToDelete" : true   },

What else am I missing here?

I've read through this: Use Survey123 with existing feature services—Survey123 for ArcGIS | ArcGIS

I'm trying to set up a survey that has multiple related tables.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

NaomiBegg2 — Sun, 14 Apr 2019 21:49:38 GMT

Hi Jake

How do we update so that apply edits on globalids is supported?

I'm in a similat boat to Jordan and seem to be going around in circles with what is supported in Pro, online and Survey123.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

roemhildtg — Tue, 30 Apr 2019 15:09:43 GMT

I'm also running into this in 10.7 on a postgres geodatabase. I've already verified that every table has archiving enabled, has globalids and the attachments use global ids.

What else is there to check?

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

BrianAnderson9 — Tue, 21 May 2019 17:10:30 GMT

I also keep having this problem and found a way to fix it. I also started with a point feature class, a related table to the point feature class, and an attachment table related to the first table. I used an Esri Guid field with the same name in all the tables for the relationships. The service published fine from ArcMap, but when I went to ArcGIS Online and looked at the JSON for each (point, table, attachment table), the point and first table (which had attachments disabled) both showed the supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds as true but the attachment table (attachments enabled) showed supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds as false. What I did was to disable the attachments from the attachment table and then re-enabled it. When I checked the JSON again it showed supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds as true. I was then able to create a survey with Survey123 Connect for ArcGIS using the published Feature Service in ArcGIS Online. I have no clue why this worked, but it did.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

roemhildtg — Thu, 30 May 2019 14:32:44 GMT

My solution to this was to go into the catalog view of the database, go to the table properties and Indexes, remove the GlobalID index, and re-add it with the Unique constraint. Do this on all layers in the feature services and supports ApplyEdits with GlobalIDS becomes true.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

CarlosSousaFerreira — Mon, 11 Nov 2019 15:00:05 GMT

This worked for me too!!!

It seems to me a little counter intuitive to have to redefine indexes created autommatically by ArcGIS tools, but it worked...

P.S.: I recreated the indexes directly in the database server, through SQL statements (Oracle DBMS)

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

JoeBryant1 — Wed, 29 Jan 2020 21:43:07 GMT

Thanks for sharing this "hack", Brian. I imagine that as Gregg points out below, this re-indexes the Global ID field for the layer with attachments enabled. But unlike Gregg, we don't have access to the RDBMS behind the scenes in an ArcGIS Online hosted feature service.

FYI: Your method worked for me only after I disabled/enabled attachments for every layer in the feature service.

I also attempted to update the service definition by editing the JSON at the rest/admin/service endpoint (accessed by inserting "/admin" between "/rest" and "/service" in the service URL). Just changing "supportsApplyEditsWithGlobalIds" : to "true" did not stick. Re-indexing the Global ID fields seems to be required.

I'm not sure if there is method to do this using the API other than the disable/enable workflow you found. Maybe someone else with more developer skills can enlighten us. This would be the preferable method so that we don't lose any current attachments in the re-indexing process.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

elpinguino — Thu, 06 May 2021 00:09:17 GMT

Hi Gregg,

Not sure if you'll see this post, but hoping someone in the thread will. I'm having this issue. If I go in to each feature layer in the feature service and turn off Enable attachments and then turn it back on, ApplyEditsWithGlobalIDs becomes true. It's fine to do this now because I'm still in the development stage, but once this goes live, that's going to be a problem if I have to keep doing this because then we'll lose any forms or images the field workers have attached. What do you mean in your post above about re-add it with the Unique constraint? What is the unique constraint? Did you do this in Arcpro or AGOL? Are you saying I shouldn't apply GlobalIDs except for the one main feature layer that everything relates back to, and for the rest only have GUIDs?

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

José_LuisCc — Mon, 20 Sep 2021 18:40:02 GMT

Activate synchronization (update disconnected with synchronization).

All right !

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

ChadBunn1 — Mon, 04 Oct 2021 23:22:38 GMT

I had to do this as well. My issue was I was importing a feature class with attachments and GlobalIDs already in place. I had to build a brand new feature class replicating the existing one. Then I needed to give it GlobalIDs, enable attachments and also enable archiving for the value to change to 'ApplyEdits with GlobalIDS : true'. After that was successful I appended my old data that I downloaded from AGOL into this new feature class.

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

roemhildtg — Tue, 07 Dec 2021 19:56:13 GMT

@elpinguino- finally got access to my account again...sorry for the delay - but for you and for anyone else who has this issue - what I mean is this:

Remove index:

https://pro.arcgis.com/en/pro-app/latest/tool-reference/data-management/remove-attribute-index.htm

Add index:

https://pro.arcgis.com/en/pro-app/latest/tool-reference/data-management/add-attribute-index.htm

you can also go into the layer properties -in pro or arc catalog and go to Indexes. From there - delete the existing index on the GUID field and re add it but be sure to check the "UNIQUE" checkbox.

The rules to ensuring that the applyEditsWithGlobalIDs is true are as follows:

1. Check that all layers and tables have a global ID and unique constraint index on them

2. Check that all attachment tables related to each layer and table has global ids

3. Ensure the attachment table relationship USES the global id field/guid in the relationship - so check the Attachments_REL relationship class and make sure that it uses the Global ID field.

4. Ensure each attachment table has the global id unique index constraint

5. Ensure all relationships for layers in the service use global ids to participate in the relationship (including attachment relationships).

You can usually browse the /arcgis/rest/services/ServiceName/MapServer/<LAYERID> endpoint of the service for each layer to see which one is the culprit .

Re: Enable Apply Edits With Global Ids on ArcGIS Feature Services

geopamplona — Fri, 25 Aug 2023 07:57:11 GMT

hello @José_LuisCc ,

i have the same problem in arcgis enterprise 10.9.1
your solution was to enable synchronization and replication in feature service?

@elpinguinoDid your approach work? recreating the attachment tables? or recreating indexes?

thanks!