idea Ground Overlay improvements in ArcGIS Earth Ideas

Ground Overlay improvements

GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde — Thu, 25 Apr 2024 15:59:12 GMT

Creating a new Ground Overlay would be easier if :

ArcGIS Earth would auto-detect the aspect ratio of the image used and adapt the existing bounding box rather than stretching the image.

The corner handles would preserve the aspect ratio (only the side handles would change it).

Thank you !

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

Anonymous User — Fri, 26 Apr 2024 02:53:02 GMT

Hello GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde

Thanks for your feedback. Your feedback and suggestions are very important to us. Your proposed improvements are very meaningful and necessary.

The good news. After our discussion and evaluation, we plan to implement the improvements in the next version.

I'll keep you updated as soon as we make some progress.

Thank you！

ZheZheng

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde — Fri, 26 Apr 2024 12:56:42 GMT

That is great @Anonymous User ! Thank you !

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

JesseCloutier — Fri, 26 Apr 2024 14:32:27 GMT

For recording purposes, 4.25.2024 post from Anonymous User belongs to @ZheZheng.

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde — Fri, 26 Apr 2024 16:02:21 GMT

Yes, when I made the comment, I saw that it was addressed to @ZheZheng. It is weird that it changed to AnonymousUser...

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

JesseCloutier — Fri, 26 Apr 2024 16:17:10 GMT

Hi @GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde, I can understand how that might look strange but can confirm it was expected. I'm a Community Managers for Esri Community and one of the things our team assists with is consolidation when a member unintentionally ends up with more than one account. When an account disappears, its posts migrate to a preservation account called Anonymous User. That's why I tagged @ZheZheng, so that their remaining account would stay subscribed to this post and there'd be a record of the change. All the best!

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

ZheZheng — Mon, 29 Apr 2024 01:49:29 GMT

Thanks, GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde , JesseCloutier I apologize for any confusion caused by using another account.

Re: Ground Overlay improvements - Status changed to: Implemented

jsphillips — Thu, 14 Nov 2024 20:16:30 GMT

Aspect ratio will be supported for Ground and Screen Overlays in v2.3, releasing this December.

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

Sharon_MU — Thu, 10 Apr 2025 02:30:58 GMT

Hi @GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde , did you have a chance to try the aspect ratio enhancement in V2.3?

I've attached the following screen recording for quick reference:

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde — Thu, 10 Apr 2025 17:52:10 GMT

Hello @Sharon_MU , the Lock Aspect Ratio enhancement is really great, thank you! It will facilitate the creation of Ground and Screen Overlays 😊

The only part that is still missing – from my personal point of view, of course – is a way to bring back the original aspect ratio of an image for a Ground Overlay. A user can bring back the original aspect ratio of an image for a Screen Overlay by using the Original Size button :

The addition of an Original Aspect Ratio button (A) would be useful for Ground Overlays. Another possibility could be to modify the behaviour of the existing Fit to screen button (B) so that it fills the screen and conserve the original aspect ratio (like in Google Earth Pro) :

Thank you !

Re: Ground Overlay improvements

Sharon_MU — Fri, 11 Apr 2025 03:15:11 GMT

Thanks @GeoffroyRicher-Lalonde for the prompt feedback and great sharing! 👍

I logged it for the internal review of our team. This function "Original Size/Aspect Ration" of Ground Overlay was not yet included in Ground Overlay for some consideration previously.

Just to share with you for your reference. Images draped on the ground can be extremely reshaped especially when the terrain is complex or the altitude is high in 3D scene or globe surface. Even the image keeps the original aspect ratio, we're not sure if it still helps in actual cases.

Anyway, I've take down your idea for further research. please stay tuned.

Thanks!