topic Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check in ArcGIS Data Reviewer Questions

Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 11:25:17 GMT

Hi,

I'm using data reviewer since few weeks and I've got a problem.
I have a shape with a merge of several other shape(polygone).
I want to know if some polygone are overlaping others in one shape. I've tried to use geometry on geometry from data reviewer but I can't because i've an error message:"unable to build error geometry for feature XX" and after an other "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX"

If someone has the solution...

Sorry for my English, I'm French.

Thank you for your help

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

DanHopkins — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 12:23:00 GMT

Is there an issue with the geometry you are trying to examine? Is it invalid geometry?

Have you tried running the Invalid Geometry Check on your data?

http://resources.arcgis.com/en/help/main/10.1/index.html#/Finding_invalid_geometry/010200000058000000/

Have you tried running the Check Geometry GP tool on your data?

http://resources.arcgis.com/en/help/main/10.1/index.html#//001700000034000000

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 12:30:14 GMT

Yes I think it's an issue with invalid geometry.

I have already tried running invalid geometry check and check geometry GP tool but it does not work.
It says that my data is clean and that I have no issue with my geometry...
I don't understand..

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

DanHopkins — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 12:36:44 GMT

1. What version of ArcGIS Data Reviewer are you running?

2. What service pack/patch have you applied?

3. Can you attach the data?

4. Can you provide the properties of your Geometry on Geometry Check?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 13:31:14 GMT

I'm running ArcGIS 10.1 with datareviewer SP1 Patch5

I'm sorry but I can't share my data..
It's a shape file from SDE L2E.

Properties of my Geometry on Geometry Check :
Feature Class 1 : my data
Feature Class 2 : the same data
Spatial Relation Check : Overlaps
Attributes : None
OK

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

DanHopkins — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 14:16:23 GMT

What tolerance did you specify?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

MichelleJohnson — Wed, 31 Jul 2013 16:58:08 GMT

Hello.

"unable to build error geometry for feature XX" and "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX" are warning messages. You should still see records written to the Reviewer table, but instead of capturing the error geometry (the geometry of where the actual overlap) it probably captured the full feature geometry. The overlap geometry could be so that it tries to create a geometry that is invalid.

Are there error records in the Reviewer table for feature "XX"?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Thu, 01 Aug 2013 06:48:21 GMT

dan2702
I can't specify any tolerance because it's grey..

I create my batch and after when I want to Validate it it's written :

'Default
Invalid Geometry Check (My data)
The Group that I create.'

Is that normal?

Meikojosan
It's right my "error" are written in the reviewer table.
"unable to build error geometry for feature XX" I have only 2 lines and for "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX" I have a lot of error. I don't understand why this difference?!
The lines from the first error message are in the reviewer table but when I click on I can only "enter correction status" "Enter Verification status" "select related row" I don't have "zoom to" "Pan to"....

Thanks to your help I have understand that I can see my data even if I have error messages. Finally it's not an issue I can work on my data through the table. And I can update the reviewer table.

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Thu, 01 Aug 2013 12:00:56 GMT

I have a new question.
For example when I run data reviewer geometry on geometry with
Properties of my Geometry on Geometry Check :
Feature Class 1 : my data
Feature Class 2 : the same data
Spatial Relation Check : intersect
tolerance: no value
Attributes : None
OK

Of course I have the same error messages. After when I look at the reviewer table I observe that I have in "category" some are Feature Record and others are Row Record. What does it mean exactly?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

MichelleJohnson — Thu, 01 Aug 2013 15:20:24 GMT

Feature records have a geometry associated with it and therefore you can zoom/pan to it. Row Records do not have a geometry.

For the "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX" message, is there more text that follows it?

There is a section in the help doc that has a list of error and warning messages. You can check that out here.

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

Annebalas — Mon, 05 Aug 2013 08:10:53 GMT

meikojosan :For the "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX" message, is there more text that follows it?
No there is not.

For the row records that means they don't have a geometry but are they intersecting anyway?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

AshleyMott — Wed, 11 Dec 2013 17:30:01 GMT

Hello.

"unable to build error geometry for feature XX" and "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX" are warning messages. You should still see records written to the Reviewer table, but instead of capturing the error geometry (the geometry of where the actual overlap) it probably captured the full feature geometry. The overlap geometry could be so that it tries to create a geometry that is invalid.

Are there error records in the Reviewer table for feature "XX"?

Michelle,
I am experiencing the same issue you have described above. My spatial reference of data and Data Reviewer are the same. This is a new issue for me. I am using SDE, so I tested this issue in a file geodatabase and do not get the error: "Unable to save error geometry... Saving feature geometry." What could be wrong with my SDE/SQL db?

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

MichelleJohnson — Wed, 11 Dec 2013 20:21:05 GMT

Ashley,

The most likely reason that you would get the message "Unable to save error geometry... Saving feature geometry" is that the check was expecting one type of geometry but was returned something different. For example, if you are looking for intersecting lines using the geometry on geomtry check, the expected return geometry is line. But it will only get a line if the lines overlap. If the lines cross, then a point geometry would be returned and therefore, return the message unable to save error geometry.

When looking for intersecting lines, it expects a line error. When looking for intersecting polygons, it expects a poly error. So when an error geometry is something other than what it is expecting, you will get that error message. (BTW, we have addressed that for 10.2.1. When looking for any type of intersections, it will always return points. So you should not get that message in those situations.)

You should still have a record of the error in the Reviewer table, but you won't have the exact error geometry. It's a warning message (not an error message), so the validation ran successfully.

Is the data you validated in the file geodatabase the exact same as the data in SDE? If it was the same check you were running, but different set of data, that could be the reason you did not get that message.

Regards,
michellej.

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

BrunoRaphael_de_Moraes — Thu, 10 Jan 2019 12:28:08 GMT

Hello.

I'm trying to execute a "Polygon Overlap/Gap is Sliver Check" with "Find Overlaps" in two cases:

Standalone using Run Data Check, the check works fine, i've got two registers with correct geometries on reviewer table.

When i try to use Reviewer Batch Validate, with the same database, version and features, i've got wrong geometries and the error "unable to save error geometry for recordID XX".

I`ve certified that my checkers was set as the same way.

Thank you for help

Re: Problem with Data Reviewer geometry on geometry check

FranciscoPerez1 — Fri, 11 Jan 2019 23:42:34 GMT

Hello,

1. Which version of ArcGIS Data Reviewer are you using?

2. Can you provide sample data?

3. Can you add an image with the properties of your Polygon Overlap/Gap Sliver Check?

Thank you.