topic Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content in ArcGIS Dashboards Questions

Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

OlyPowers — Thu, 15 Apr 2021 14:53:52 GMT

In October I created a series of dashboards using Dashboards Beta for one of our departments. The feature they loved the most was being able to click on the columns in the serial charts, and have only those features show up on the map. The filter action between the serial chart and the map worked in October. Here I am in April now, trying to create another of these dashboards for another department. I have set up everything the same as I did the previous ones. However when I go to add the filter action for the serial chart, the map layer is not showing up as a target at all. I have quadruple checked that the serial chart is using the correct data source. It is. I have recreated the serial chart several times. Finally I went back to dashboard that I know was working to find out that the filtering from the serial chart to the map is no longer working. When I go to the action panel in the chart, "The target element has a configuration issue" is showing up underneath the map layer target. Something has happened recently that's not allowing the map layers to be used as filter targets anymore. This is a great feature that a lot of people use to explore the data, why is it no longer working?

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

GeorgiaCummins — Fri, 16 Apr 2021 00:19:05 GMT

ArcGIS Dashboards is out of Beta now (https://community.esri.com/t5/arcgis-dashboards-blog/new-arcgis-dashboards-is-out-of-beta/ba-p/1047133/jump-to/first-unread-message)
I have a dashboard that is no longer working too. I think this might be the reason.

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

JohnSolly4 — Fri, 16 Apr 2021 23:59:50 GMT

Hello,

We have a known limitation where map services cannot be used to perform filter actions in grouped value charts. We are working on a fix, but it didn't make it into the latest release.

As the other user mentioned, we just came out of beta, so accessing Dashboards from your content page now point to the new dashboards.

Can you let me know if there is a difference between opening the dashboard from the following two locations?

https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/home

https://www.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards

I am suspecting you are using a map service for your chart. We have known limitations with map services taking part in filtering other elements (like the map).

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

OlyPowers — Mon, 19 Apr 2021 21:12:36 GMT

It only opens in the second link. The dashboards were created in beta and do not exist in classic.

That's interesting that there are known limitations for filtering from feature services when that was definitely working before.

After a lot of testing today I was able to get the filtering working by converting our map service to a feature service, and re-adding the layers to the maps one at a time. This is still going to be a lot of working to re-point and re symbolize everything, but it'll get the dashboard working the way we need it to.

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

JohnSolly4 — Tue, 20 Apr 2021 18:52:27 GMT

I suggest reaching out to support about any Dashboards that are not opening.

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

OlyPowers — Thu, 29 Apr 2021 15:26:42 GMT

I mean that's not really the problem. A dashboard that was created in Beta simply doesn't exist in Classic. That was never the issue.

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

JohnSolly4 — Thu, 29 Apr 2021 18:45:53 GMT

I think I see what you are saying @OlyPowers

When you create or save a dashboard using the latest Dashboard, https://www.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards you will no longer be able to open that dashboard using the Classic application, https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard

These are two separate applications. The latest Dashboards will be able to open and edit older dashboards, but you won't be able to use the older application to open newer dashboards.

I hope that clarified things? I am doing my best to understand the problem you are raising!

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

BrittanyBurson — Wed, 10 Nov 2021 21:01:03 GMT

Hi @JohnSolly4 - Enterprise 10.8.1 here.

Is one of the known limitations with "grouped" rest service endpoints? I can't seem to get the Filter Map option for the map when using the service URL of

https://maps.example.gov/arcgis/rest/services/Example/Utilities_Example/MapServer

but I can if I use the single endpoint URL in the map..

https://maps.example.gov/arcgis/rest/services/Example/Utilities_Example/MapServer/4

If it is not the group, is there something else causing it?

Thank you

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

MoyaCalvert_01 — Thu, 03 Mar 2022 05:38:38 GMT

@JohnSolly4 is there an update on this issue - reading this - you say "map services cannot be used to perform filter actions in grouped value charts. We are working on a fix, but it didn't make it into the latest release", written nearly 10 months ago.

I am using a hosted service on ArcGIS Online, one of the best features was that you could click on a bar in the serial chart and the map would filter to display the data from that bar. but this feature has disappeared (!) My chart is set up for Grouped values, so I am figuring this is the problem. but there doesn't seem to be a solution???

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

ShaneBradt — Fri, 13 May 2022 03:09:00 GMT

Hi @JohnSolly4! I agree with @MoyaCalvert_01 - I love using a bar graph to let users filter other content. The only way I can create the graph I need is by using grouped values. Can you provide any update on the fix to this issue? Thanks!

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

amarcz_cc — Fri, 05 Aug 2022 00:26:30 GMT

@OlyPowers

Hi there,

I am able to filter my Feature Layer inside my Dashboard using the Data > Group Values. The way I solved this was to verify my Web Map used in the Dashboard had Hosted Features Layers (not Map Image Layers) in it, and that the Serial Chart Frame > Configuration > Data > Layer: <your layer here> was pointing to the 'Layers from <your web map> map: <your layer here>.

That allowed me to go into Actions, and filter based on said layer.

Hope this helps you all.

My environment is Enterprise 10.9

Using Dashboards (not classic)

Using a Web Map created in Portal (not published from ArcPro)

Re: Serial Charts no longer able to filter map content

TimothyRudzik — Mon, 30 Oct 2023 18:59:28 GMT

We are having a similar issue with a feature service in a serial chart no longer filtering the map view after upgrading from 10.8.1 to 10.9.1.

As a clean test I published a new feature service (one layer), added it to a new Portal map as two separate instances (a copy) of the same feature service. I symbolized the first instance using unique symbols. I symbolized the second instance using Heat Map symbology. I then created a new Dashboard (not using Classic). In the new Dashboard I created two serial charts, each pointing to a different instance of the same feature service. Both using categories from Grouped Values, and each with a filter action pointing at their respective feature service instance.

The feature service instance using unique symbols filters the map as it should.

The feature service instance using Heat Map symbology DOES NOT FILTER the map.

Can anyone on 10.9.1 replicate this result? If so then maybe this should be listed as a breaking change for anyone upgrading to 10.9.1, as it worked fine in 10.8.1.