topic Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer in 3D Questions

Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

Anonymous User — Tue, 13 May 2014 22:13:13 GMT

Original User: dmede

I'm attempting a relatively straight forward process, creating a 3d multipatch feature class from an extruded 2d feature class via the 'Layer 3d to Feature Class' tool. However all my new multipatch layers are flat.

The input is a simple building foot print layer in UTM Zone 11. I'm using properties to extrude the footprints to 30m meters. Then using Layer 3d to Feature Class to create a new 3d layer of the footprints. The tool runs without error but the output is flat, the extruded shapes are not retained.

The tool help is no help.

Any idea what the issue may be?

Extruded 2d:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]33793[/ATTACH]

New Multipatch layer:
[ATTACH=CONFIG]33794[/ATTACH]

Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

JakubSisak — Wed, 14 May 2014 19:23:50 GMT

This is almost certainly a bug! I get the same result with a simple single feature.

Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

Anonymous User — Wed, 14 May 2014 21:58:45 GMT

Original User: dmede

Thanks for posting, I'm sure you're right. I was going to run the same test in a bit, with a single new feature rather than an imported footprint layer.

I'm on 10.2.1 so I can only hope this was addressed in 10.2.2. I'll upgrade and retry.

I can't think of any other product that costs as much as ArcGIS and fails as often, but is still regarded as 'functional' and not beta.

Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

DavidMedeiros — Thu, 15 May 2014 19:49:27 GMT

Installed 10.2.2, no change. Layer 3d to Feature Class does not work as intended.

Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

DavidMedeiros — Thu, 15 May 2014 19:55:19 GMT

Solved!

Layer 3d to Feature Class works ok if Background Processing is turned off.

You're welcome Esri!

Side note to other users: background processing is the source of a large number of issues in ArcGIS, it's a good tip to always try a broken feature with it off. Just took me a while to remember that this time.

Re: Layer 3d to Feature Class results in flat output layer

Anonymous User — Fri, 16 May 2014 13:36:43 GMT

Original User: jakubsisak

Solved!

Layer 3d to Feature Class works ok if Background Processing is turned off.

You're welcome Esri!

Side note to other users: background processing is the source of a large number of issues in ArcGIS, it's a good tip to always try a broken feature with it off. Just took me a while to remember that this time.

Good to know! i posted this on GIS SE and someone also suggested to turn off background processing but also that this is a known bug that was fixed in 10.2.2. Apparently not! Good work bro!

With 10.2 being the most buggy and hands-down the worst release ever and with ArcGIS Pro so far completely unusable for serious production (maybe 5 - 10 years away? and not much hope unless a great re-design effort is put into it) I don't know where this whole upgrade path is going. The UC presentations sure made it look good but hands-on reveals a path to hell rather then the cloud.